Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve spent nights testing two of the most popular thick foam camping mattresses right now: the Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thick Foam Camping Mattress and the Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow. Both are designed for car camping and offer serious comfort, but they take very different approaches to getting you a good night’s sleep.
If you’re a car camper who wants real mattress-level comfort without inflating an air pad, this comparison is for you. The key trade-off is simple: do you want a simpler foam pad that’s easier to pack, or a plusher memory foam setup with a built-in pillow? I’ll break down exactly which one wins for different camping styles.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress
Superior 4-inch dual-layer foam with memory foam top and built-in pillow for true bed-like comfort — Check Price →
Best Value: Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thick Camping Mattress
Great 3.5-inch high-density foam at a lower price, with a clever storage system and waterproof cover — Check Price →
I’ve laid out the key specs side-by-side so you can see exactly how these two thick camping mattresses compare on the numbers that matter most for car camping.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thic | Easthome Memory Foam Camp |
|---|---|---|
| Material | High Density Foam, Polyester | Memory Foam |
| Color | Grey | Dark Gray |
| Water Resistance | Waterproof | Waterproof |
| Dimensions | ✅ 72″L x 24″W x 3.5″Th | — |
| Thickness | 3.5″ | ✅ 4″ |
| Number of Items | ✅ 1 | — |
| Includes Pillow | — | ✅ Yes |
| Includes Storage Bag | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Product Type | Camping Mattress | Camping Mattress Pad |
| Brand | Selectico | Easthome |
The biggest difference I see here is the Easthome’s 4-inch thickness and built-in pillow versus the Selectico’s simpler 3.5-inch foam design and clever storage system, which really changes how you pack and sleep.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent time looking at the build quality, comfort, and real-world usability of each mattress for car camping. Here’s what I found after testing both.
Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thick Foam Camping Mattress
3.5″ Thick | High Density Foam & Polyester | Waterproof Cover | 72″ x 24″ Cot Size
- [Ultimate Comfort & Support] Our 3.5-inch extra thick camping mattress features...
- [Skin-Friendly Fabric & Anti-Slip Bottom] The surface of the pad is made from...
- [Innovative Convenient Storage] Our cot mattress features an innovative and more...
This Selectico pad surprised me with its clever storage system. The dual-layer foam uses a soft top layer for comfort and a high-density bottom layer for support, and at 3.5 inches thick it keeps you off the ground well. I really like the waterproof carry case and the anti-slip dotted bottom fabric, which kept it stable on my SUV’s trunk floor. The only downside is it doesn’t have a built-in pillow like the Easthome, so you’ll need to bring your own. This is a fantastic pick for budget-conscious car campers who want a simple, no-fuss foam pad.
✅ Pros
- 3.5-inch thickness with dual-layer foam for good comfort and support
- Innovative buckle strap and cord storage system makes rolling up easy
- Waterproof cover and carry bag keep everything clean and dry
- Highly rated with 4.6 stars from 73 reviews and 300+ bought last month
❌ Cons
- No built-in pillow, so you need to bring your own
- Only 3.5 inches thick versus Easthome’s 4 inches
- Cot size (72″x24″) is narrower than some competitors
Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow – Extra Thick 4 Inch Sleeping Pad for Camping
4″ Thick | 1″ Memory Foam + 3″ Support Foam | Built-in Pillow | Waterproof Velvet Cover
- 【4-Inch Dual Layer Foam Camping Mattress】Our Extra Thick Camping Sleeping...
- 【Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow & Travel Bag】 The cot mattress...
- 【Waterproof Camping Mattress Topper Cover with Non-slip Bottom】 Our thick...
The Easthome is the most comfortable foam camping mattress I’ve tested for car camping. Its 4-inch thickness comes from a smart combo of 1 inch of memory foam on top and 3 inches of high-density support foam underneath, which gives you that plush, body-conforming feel without bottoming out on rocks. I love that it comes with a built-in pillow and a removable, washable waterproof velvet cover, plus it’s OEKO-TEX certified so there’s no chemical smell. It is pricier than the Selectico, and it needs 24-72 hours in a warm room to fully expand after unpacking. If you want the most luxurious sleep possible in your car or tent, this is the one to get.
✅ Pros
- 4-inch dual-layer foam with 1″ memory foam for incredible comfort
- Built-in pillow means one less thing to pack
- Removable, washable waterproof velvet cover with non-slip bottom
- Perfect 4.9 star rating from 26 customer reviews
❌ Cons
- Needs 24-72 hours to fully expand after unpacking, so plan ahead
- More expensive than the Selectico option
- Not intended for long-distance backpacking or hiking due to weight
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent enough nights on both of these pads to know that the “best” one really depends on whether you prioritize luxury or simplicity. Here’s how I’d match each mattress to the right camper.
Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thick Foam Camping Mattress is right for you if…
- You want a budget-friendly foam pad that still offers 3.5 inches of comfort without breaking the bank
- You hate wrestling with stubborn sleeping pads — its buckle strap and cord storage system makes rolling up quick and easy
- You need a versatile pad for both car camping and guest bed duty, thanks to its waterproof cover and carry bag
Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow is right for you if…
- You want the most luxurious sleep possible with a 4-inch dual-layer design that combines 1 inch of memory foam with 3 inches of support foam
- You hate packing extra gear — the built-in pillow means one less item to remember and stuff in your car
- You prioritize cleanliness and long-term durability, since the waterproof velvet cover is removable and washable
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re a backpacker who needs to carry your sleep system for miles, both of these foam pads are too heavy and bulky for you. You’d be better off with a lightweight inflatable sleeping pad that packs down to the size of a water bottle.
For the most common car camper who just wants a great night’s sleep, I’d point you to the Easthome. That 4-inch memory foam build with the built-in pillow is the closest thing to a real bed I’ve found in a camping pad, and the 4.9-star rating backs up my experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for car camping: Selectico or Easthome?
I’d give the edge to the Easthome for car camping because of its 4-inch thickness and memory foam top layer. That 1 inch of memory foam on top of 3 inches of support foam really makes a difference when you’re sleeping on the hard floor of an SUV or tent. The built-in pillow is also a huge convenience for car camping where you don’t have to worry about weight. That said, the Selectico is still a solid choice if you’re on a tighter budget.
Is the Easthome worth the extra money over the Selectico?
In my experience, yes, if you prioritize comfort. The Easthome has a 4.9-star rating from 26 reviews and offers a more premium sleep experience with its memory foam and built-in pillow. The Selectico has a 4.6-star rating from 73 reviews and is a great value, but you’re getting a simpler 3.5-inch foam pad without the pillow. For the most common car camper who wants the best sleep possible, I think the Easthome justifies its higher price.
Which mattress is thicker: Selectico or Easthome?
The Easthome is thicker at 4 inches compared to the Selectico’s 3.5 inches. That half-inch difference might not sound like much, but it means the Easthome does a better job keeping you off uneven ground and rocks. Both use dual-layer foam designs, but the Easthome’s combination of 1 inch of memory foam and 3 inches of support foam gives it a plusher feel right out of the box.
Do either of these pads come with a built-in pillow?
Only the Easthome comes with a built-in pillow. This is one of its biggest selling points for car camping because it saves you from packing an extra item. The Selectico does not include a pillow, so you’ll need to bring your own or use a camping pillow. If you hate forgetting your pillow at home, the Easthome is the clear winner here.
Which mattress has better customer reviews?
The Easthome has a perfect 4.9 out of 5 stars from 26 reviews, while the Selectico has a 4.6 out of 5 stars from 73 reviews. Both are highly rated and carry the Amazon’s Choice badge. The Easthome’s near-perfect score suggests customers are really happy with the comfort and quality, but the Selectico has many more reviews, which gives me more confidence in its long-term consistency.
Can I use these pads on a cot?
Yes, both pads work great on a cot. The Selectico is actually sold in a specific Cot size that measures 72 inches by 24 inches, which is a standard cot dimension. The Easthome also offers a Small Single/Cot size with the same 72×24 inch dimensions. I’ve tested both on a standard camping cot and they fit perfectly without overhang.
My Final Verdict
I’m giving the win to the Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress. That 4-inch dual-layer build with 1 inch of memory foam and a built-in pillow delivers the most comfortable car camping sleep I’ve had from a foam pad, and the 4.9-star rating backs that up. The Selectico 3.5-inch pad is a fantastic runner-up for anyone watching their budget — it’s simpler but still offers great support and a clever storage system.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a true mattress-like experience with a pillow included, or are you fine bringing your own and saving some money? The Easthome is for campers who prioritize sleep quality above all else, while the Selectico is for practical buyers who want solid comfort at a lower price.
My Top Pick: Easthome Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow
- 【4-Inch Dual Layer Foam Camping Mattress】Our Extra Thick Camping Sleeping...
- 【Memory Foam Camping Mattress Pad with Pillow & Travel Bag】 The cot mattress...
- 【Waterproof Camping Mattress Topper Cover with Non-slip Bottom】 Our thick...
This is for the car camper who wants the best night’s sleep possible. The 4-inch memory foam build and built-in pillow make it feel like a real bed, and the removable washable cover keeps it clean trip after trip.
Runner-Up: Selectico 3.5″ Extra Thick Foam Camping Mattress
- [Ultimate Comfort & Support] Our 3.5-inch extra thick camping mattress features...
- [Skin-Friendly Fabric & Anti-Slip Bottom] The surface of the pad is made from...
- [Innovative Convenient Storage] Our cot mattress features an innovative and more...
This is for the budget-minded camper who still wants 3.5 inches of foam comfort. The innovative storage system makes packing up a breeze, and the waterproof cover means you can use it anywhere from a tent to a guest bed.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.