Avoid These 5 Mistakes When Buying a Double Mattress -

Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Buying a double mattress might seem straightforward, but many shoppers make costly mistakes that lead to discomfort, poor sleep quality, and even wasted money. With so many options available, it’s easy to overlook crucial factors like mattress firmness, material, and size compatibility with your bed frame.

Quick Answer: To avoid making a bad purchase, steer clear of common mistakes such as choosing the wrong firmness, ignoring mattress materials, or overlooking warranty and return policies. A well-informed decision will ensure a comfortable and supportive sleep experience.

Table of Contents

Our Top Picks for the Best Double Mattresses

If you’re in a hurry, here are three highly rated double mattresses that offer exceptional comfort, durability, and value for money:

Emma Original Memory Foam Mattress

This award-winning mattress provides excellent pressure relief and body contouring, making it a great choice for side and back sleepers.

Simba Hybrid Mattress

Featuring a mix of memory foam and pocket springs, this mattress balances support and breathability, reducing motion transfer and overheating.

Silentnight Miracoil Mattress

Ideal for those needing extra back support, this mattress offers a firm feel with zoned support for spinal alignment.

Choosing the Wrong Firmness Level

One of the biggest mistakes when buying a double mattress is selecting the wrong firmness level. Your comfort and spinal alignment depend on finding the right balance between softness and support.

How Firmness Affects Sleep

Firmness directly impacts your sleep posture and overall comfort. A mattress that is too soft may cause excessive sinking, leading to back pain. On the other hand, a mattress that is too firm can create pressure points, especially for side sleepers.

Matching Firmness to Sleeping Position

Side Sleepers – A soft to medium mattress (3-6 on the firmness scale) provides better contouring to the shoulders and hips.
Back Sleepers – A medium to firm mattress (5-7 on the firmness scale) supports spinal alignment.
Stomach Sleepers – A firm mattress (7-9 on the firmness scale) prevents the lower back from sinking too much.

How to Test Mattress Firmness

In-Store: Lie down in your normal sleeping position for at least 10 minutes to gauge comfort.
Online Purchases: Look for trial periods (usually 100 nights or more) to test firmness at home.
Check Firmness Ratings: Most brands provide a firmness scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest.

Ignoring Mattress Materials and Construction

Another common mistake when buying a double mattress is neglecting the importance of materials and construction. The type of material used affects durability, comfort, breathability, and support.

Types of Mattress Materials

Understanding the differences between mattress materials can help you choose the right one for your needs:

Memory Foam – Excellent for pressure relief and motion isolation but may trap heat unless infused with cooling gel.

Innerspring – Traditional coil-based mattresses offer good airflow and firm support but may produce noise and motion transfer.
Hybrid – A combination of memory foam and pocket springs, providing both contouring comfort and responsive support.
Latex – Naturally hypoallergenic, eco-friendly, and highly durable with a responsive and bouncy feel.

Why Material Matters

Choosing the wrong material can result in discomfort and poor sleep quality. For instance:

If you overheat at night, avoid memory foam without cooling technology.
If you need strong back support, a firm hybrid or latex mattress is ideal.

If you sleep with a restless partner, memory foam or a hybrid with pocket springs reduces motion transfer.

How to Choose the Right Construction

Check Layer Composition – A good mattress should have a balance of comfort and support layers.
Look at Density and ILD (Indentation Load Deflection) Ratings – These indicate firmness and durability.

Consider Edge Support – Strong edges prevent sagging and provide stability.

Overlooking Mattress Size and Bed Frame Compatibility

Many buyers focus only on comfort and price, forgetting to check if the mattress fits their space and bed frame. This can lead to awkward gaps, an unstable sleeping surface, or even the need to purchase a new bed frame.

Standard Double Mattress Dimensions

A standard double mattress measures 135 cm x 190 cm (54″ x 75″), but variations exist:

European Double – Slightly longer at 140 cm x 200 cm (55″ x 79″).
Small Double (Three-Quarter) – More compact at 120 cm x 190 cm (47″ x 75″).

Why Size Matters

If your mattress is too big, it won’t fit your existing frame or bed base properly.

If it’s too small, there may be gaps, leading to instability and reduced comfort.
The room size should also be considered—ensure there’s enough space for movement and furniture.

How to Ensure Compatibility

Measure Your Bed Frame: Always check the exact inner dimensions before purchasing.

Consider Adjustable Beds: Some modern bed frames allow for slight variations in mattress size.
Check the Mattress Thickness: A very thick mattress (over 30 cm) may not suit all bed frames, especially those with low headboards or platform designs.

Ignoring Warranty, Trial Period, and Return Policy

Many buyers focus solely on comfort and price, overlooking the importance of warranties and return policies. A mattress is a long-term investment, and without proper buyer protection, you could end up stuck with a mattress that doesn’t suit your needs.

Why a Warranty Matters

A good warranty covers manufacturing defects, premature sagging, and structural failures. Key things to check include:

Length of Coverage: Most high-quality mattresses offer 10 to 15 years of warranty.
What’s Covered: Ensure it includes sagging (typically over 1 inch), broken coils, and stitching defects.

Prorated vs. Non-Prorated: Non-prorated warranties cover full replacements, while prorated ones may require partial payment.

Importance of a Sleep Trial

Buying a mattress online or in-store doesn’t always guarantee the perfect feel. That’s why trial periods are essential:

Standard Trial Length: Most reputable brands offer 100 to 365 nights to test the mattress.

Return Conditions: Some require the mattress to be used for at least 30 days before initiating a return.
Refund or Exchange: Check if you’ll get a full refund or only store credit.

Return Policy Considerations

Return Fees: Some brands charge a pickup fee for returns.

Condition Requirements: Ensure you use a mattress protector, as stains can void returns.
Retailer vs. Manufacturer Policies: If buying from a third-party seller, confirm if the return policy matches the brand’s terms.

Not Considering Motion Isolation and Edge Support

Many shoppers overlook motion isolation and edge support, two critical factors that impact comfort—especially for couples or restless sleepers. A mattress without these features can lead to sleep disturbances and reduced durability.

Motion Isolation: Why It Matters

If you share a bed, motion isolation prevents you from feeling every toss and turn of your partner. Poor motion isolation can disrupt sleep, leading to fatigue and discomfort.

Best Mattress Types for Motion Isolation

Memory Foam: Absorbs movement effectively, making it ideal for couples.
Hybrid (With Pocket Springs): Reduces motion transfer better than traditional innerspring mattresses.

Latex: Provides decent motion isolation while maintaining responsiveness.

Worst Mattress Type for Motion Isolation

Innerspring (Open Coil): Traditional coil mattresses tend to transfer motion across the entire bed.

Edge Support: Why It’s Important

Weak edges can lead to sagging, making it difficult to sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you might roll off. Strong edge support increases mattress durability and provides a stable surface.

Best Options for Edge Support

Hybrid Mattresses with Reinforced Edges – Pocket springs with foam encasements improve edge stability.
High-Density Foam Mattresses – Firmer foam layers prevent sinking near the edges.

Signs of Poor Edge Support

Mattress collapses when you sit on the edge.

The sleeping area feels smaller because edges lack firmness.

Conclusion

Buying a double mattress is a significant investment, and avoiding common mistakes can ensure a comfortable and long-lasting choice. To recap, make sure to:

Choose the right firmness based on your sleeping position.

Consider mattress materials to match your comfort, support, and breathability needs.
Check size and bed frame compatibility to avoid fitting issues.
Understand the warranty, trial period, and return policy for buyer protection.

Prioritize motion isolation and edge support for uninterrupted sleep and durability.

A well-informed purchase leads to better sleep quality and long-term satisfaction. If you’re ready to find the perfect mattress, explore options with strong warranties, trial periods, and high customer ratings.

Ready to Buy? Here is a Budget-Friendly Recommendation for You!

If you’re looking for a high-quality double mattress without breaking the bank, consider these top budget-friendly options:

Nectar Memory Foam Mattress

Offers excellent pressure relief and motion isolation at an affordable price. Comes with a 365-night trial and a forever warranty for peace of mind.

Molblly Double Memory Foam Mattress

A cost-effective option with certified foam layers that provide comfort and breathability. Ideal for those who need medium-firm support on a budget.

Inofia Hybrid Mattress

Features a mix of pocket springs and foam for balanced support and durability. Great for those who want affordable edge support and motion isolation.

FAQs

Here are answers to some common questions about buying a double mattress:

How do I know which firmness level is right for me?

The right firmness depends on your sleeping position and personal preference:

Side sleepers: Soft to medium (3-6 on the firmness scale) for better pressure relief.

Back sleepers: Medium to firm (5-7) to support spinal alignment.
Stomach sleepers: Firm (7-9) to prevent excessive sinking.
If you’re unsure, a medium-firm mattress (5-6) is often the safest option.

What’s the average lifespan of a double mattress?

A good-quality mattress lasts 7 to 10 years. Factors like material, usage, and maintenance impact longevity. Memory foam and hybrid mattresses typically last 8-10 years, while innerspring models may need replacement sooner.

Can I use my old bed frame with a new double mattress?

It depends on the frame size and mattress thickness. Ensure your bed frame matches the 135 cm x 190 cm (54″ x 75″) standard double size. If using a slatted base, the gaps between slats should be less than 7 cm apart to prevent sagging.

Do I really need a mattress trial period?

Yes! A trial period (typically 100-365 nights) lets you test the mattress at home. Since comfort preferences vary, a risk-free trial ensures you can return or exchange it if it doesn’t suit your needs.

How can I prevent my mattress from sagging?

Rotate it every 3-6 months to distribute wear evenly.

Use a supportive bed base (avoid weak or widely spaced slats).
Choose a mattress with high-density foam or reinforced edges.
Avoid sitting on the edges frequently, as this weakens structural integrity.

What’s the best budget double mattress?

If you’re looking for affordability without sacrificing comfort, some top-rated budget options include:

Nectar Memory Foam Mattress – Best for comfort and pressure relief.
Molblly Double Memory Foam Mattress – A great balance of affordability and quality.

Inofia Hybrid Mattress – Provides strong edge support and durability at a low price.

How do I clean and maintain my mattress?

Use a mattress protector to prevent stains and dust buildup.
Vacuum it monthly to remove dust mites and allergens.

Spot clean stains using mild detergent and warm water.
Keep it dry—avoid spills and ensure proper airflow to prevent mold growth.