Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding: Which Mattress is the Better Buy? -

Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

When it comes to choosing a mattress, the decision can be overwhelming with the many options available on the market. Two of the most talked-about brands in the industry are Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding. Both offer high-quality mattresses with unique features, but which one truly stands out?

Quick Answer: Both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding provide excellent mattresses, but your choice ultimately depends on your preferences in terms of materials, firmness, and sleep needs. Avocado is known for its eco-friendly latex options, while Brooklyn Bedding offers a more diverse range of options for various sleeping styles and budgets.

Table of Contents

Our Top Picks for Mattresses

If you’re still unsure, here are our top three mattress recommendations for your best night’s sleep:

Avocado Green Mattress

Ideal for eco-conscious shoppers who love natural materials and need firm support. It’s our top pick for sustainable comfort.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A versatile hybrid mattress offering excellent support and comfort for all types of sleepers.

Avocado Vegan Mattress

Perfect for those who want an organic, cruelty-free mattress without compromising comfort.

Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding: Mattress Materials & Construction

When choosing between Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding, one of the most significant factors is the materials used in the construction of their mattresses. Both brands pride themselves on quality, but they take different approaches when it comes to the types of materials used.

Avocado Mattress Materials

Avocado is a standout brand for eco-conscious consumers, with mattresses made primarily from organic and sustainable materials. Their mattresses feature:

Organic Latex: Sourced from rubber trees, Avocado’s latex is natural and free from harmful chemicals. It offers firm support and is highly breathable, perfect for hot sleepers.
Organic Cotton: Used for the cover, this cotton is GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certified, ensuring it’s grown without harmful pesticides.
Wool: Avocado incorporates organic wool in their mattresses for added softness and natural flame resistance. The wool also regulates temperature, keeping you warm in winter and cool in summer.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Materials

Brooklyn Bedding, while not as focused on organic materials as Avocado, still provides excellent options with a variety of configurations. Some key features include:

Memory Foam: The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid, for example, uses high-quality memory foam for pressure relief, contouring to your body while ensuring that you don’t sink too deeply.
Pocketed Coils: The Signature Hybrid also features individually pocketed coils, providing targeted support for your body. This construction helps with motion isolation, making it a great choice for couples.

Gel Infused Foam: Some of their mattresses, like the Titan Luxe, incorporate gel-infused foam to regulate temperature and prevent heat retention during sleep.

Comfort and Firmness: Which Mattress Offers Better Support?

Comfort and firmness are often the deciding factors when purchasing a mattress. Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding both offer excellent options in this area, but they cater to different preferences in terms of firmness and overall feel.

Avocado Mattress Comfort and Firmness

Avocado mattresses are known for their firm support, making them ideal for individuals who prefer a more supportive surface. Their latex construction offers a responsive feel that doesn’t allow you to sink too deep into the mattress.

Firmness Levels: Avocado offers two firmness options: a standard medium-firm (7/10 on the firmness scale) and a plush option (5.5/10) for those who want a softer surface. The standard version is the most popular, providing optimal support for back and stomach sleepers.
Pressure Relief: Latex provides excellent pressure relief, especially for side sleepers. It allows your body to rest evenly while maintaining spinal alignment. However, individuals who prefer more cushion or deeper contouring may not find the plushness they desire.
Edge Support: Thanks to its hybrid design, Avocado’s mattresses offer great edge support, preventing sagging when you sit on the edges.

Brooklyn Bedding Comfort and Firmness

Brooklyn Bedding takes a more diverse approach to firmness, offering a range of options to suit all types of sleepers. From soft to firm, their mattresses provide a variety of choices for different needs.

Firmness Levels: Brooklyn Bedding offers various firmness options for their mattresses, including soft, medium, and firm (ranging from 3 to 8 on the firmness scale). This makes it easier to find a match for your sleep style.
Pressure Relief: Thanks to the combination of foam and coils, their mattresses offer a balanced feel. The memory foam provides pressure relief for side sleepers, while the hybrid designs offer the support necessary for back and stomach sleepers.

Customization: For those who like customization, Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress line allows you to select your desired firmness for a more personalized sleep experience.

Durability and Longevity: Which Mattress Will Last Longer?

When investing in a mattress, durability is an important factor to consider. You want to ensure that the mattress you choose will provide consistent support and comfort over the years. Both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding offer high-quality mattresses, but how do they compare in terms of longevity?

Avocado Mattress Durability

Avocado mattresses are known for their impressive durability due to the high-quality, natural materials used in their construction. Here’s how they stack up:

Natural Latex: One of the most durable materials in the mattress industry, latex can last between 10-15 years without losing its shape or comfort. This means an Avocado mattress is likely to hold up over time, even with regular use.
Organic Cotton and Wool: Both materials are known for their longevity. Organic cotton is not only soft but also resilient, while wool is naturally flame-resistant and can endure for years without deteriorating.
High-Quality Construction: The craftsmanship of Avocado mattresses, with their hybrid design and attention to detail, contributes to long-lasting support and comfort. With proper care, these mattresses tend to maintain their structural integrity for years.

Brooklyn Bedding Durability

Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are also made with durable materials, but the longevity can vary based on the specific model you choose.

Foam and Hybrid Construction: The durability of memory foam and hybrid mattresses is generally good, with most Brooklyn Bedding mattresses lasting 7-10 years. However, memory foam mattresses may show signs of wear, such as sagging, after several years of use.
Titanium Coils: In their hybrid models, Brooklyn Bedding uses strong coils to enhance durability and prevent sagging. These coils help the mattress maintain its shape over time, offering better support than traditional spring mattresses.

High-Density Foams: Brooklyn Bedding’s high-density foams are designed to withstand heavy use, contributing to the overall durability of their mattresses. They are less likely to develop indentations or impressions over time compared to standard memory foam mattresses.

Price and Value for Money: Which Mattress Offers the Best Deal?

Price is a crucial consideration when choosing a mattress. While both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding offer high-quality products, their price points can differ significantly. This section will explore how each brand’s pricing compares and whether they offer good value for your investment.

Avocado Mattress Pricing

Avocado’s mattresses are positioned in the higher-end market, mainly due to the use of organic and sustainable materials. However, they offer great value for money in terms of quality and longevity.

Price Range: Avocado mattresses typically range from $1,000 to $2,000, depending on the size and specific model. The Avocado Green Mattress, for instance, starts around $1,199 for a queen size, while the Avocado Vegan Mattress is priced similarly.
Value for Money: While the price may seem steep at first glance, the longevity and eco-friendly construction make it a worthwhile investment for those who value sustainability and long-lasting comfort. Additionally, Avocado offers a 1-year sleep trial and a 25-year warranty, which adds significant value to your purchase.

Brooklyn Bedding Pricing

Brooklyn Bedding offers more budget-friendly options without compromising on quality. Their mattresses provide a range of price points to accommodate different budgets, from more affordable models to higher-end hybrids.

Price Range: Brooklyn Bedding’s prices range from as low as $599 for their more basic models to around $1,700 for their premium hybrid mattresses. For example, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid starts at $899 for a queen size.
Value for Money: Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses deliver excellent value, particularly for those who are looking for a high-quality hybrid or foam mattress at a more affordable price. They also offer a 120-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty, ensuring a risk-free purchase.

Which One Offers Better Value?

While Avocado’s eco-friendly, natural materials justify its higher price, Brooklyn Bedding delivers a similar level of comfort and durability at a more accessible price. If sustainability and long-term investment are top priorities, Avocado might be worth the extra cost.

Customer Experience: Reviews, Return Policies, and Warranty

When making a mattress purchase, the overall customer experience is vital. This includes how well the mattress performs over time, the company’s return policies, and their customer service reputation. Both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding have established themselves in the market with strong customer service, but let’s take a closer look at what each brand offers.

Avocado Customer Experience

Avocado prides itself on providing a premium customer experience with a focus on transparency and sustainability.

Customer Reviews: Avocado mattresses consistently receive high ratings for their comfort, durability, and eco-friendly materials. Many customers praise the mattress for its firm support and natural feel, although some note that the firm options might be too stiff for those used to softer mattresses.

Return Policy: Avocado offers a 100-night sleep trial, giving you a generous window to decide if the mattress is right for you. If you’re not satisfied, you can return it for a full refund.
Warranty: Avocado offers a 25-year warranty, one of the longest in the industry. This extensive coverage adds significant peace of mind for buyers, ensuring that your mattress is protected for many years.

Brooklyn Bedding Customer Experience

Brooklyn Bedding is known for offering exceptional customer service and flexibility, with a focus on providing a tailored sleep experience.

Customer Reviews: Customers frequently highlight the variety of firmness options available with Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, making them a great choice for people with specific sleep preferences. The Signature Hybrid, in particular, garners praise for its balanced support and comfort. However, some users note that their hybrid models may take some time to break in.
Return Policy: Brooklyn Bedding provides a 120-night sleep trial, which is longer than many other mattress brands. If you are unsatisfied within that period, you can return the mattress for a full refund. The company also offers a generous return policy with minimal hassle, ensuring that customers can make a risk-free purchase.
Warranty: Brooklyn Bedding offers a 10-year warranty on their mattresses. While not as long as Avocado’s, this is still a solid guarantee for the longevity of your purchase.

Which Brand Offers the Best Customer Experience?

Both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding offer excellent customer service, but there are some differences. Avocado’s extended warranty and commitment to sustainability make it an appealing choice for eco-conscious buyers who are willing to invest more. On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding provides a longer sleep trial and a more straightforward return process, making it an excellent option for those who prioritize flexibility and convenience.

Conclusion

In the battle of Avocado vs Brooklyn Bedding, both brands offer high-quality mattresses, but the choice ultimately comes down to your personal preferences. Avocado stands out for its eco-friendly materials, natural latex, and long-lasting durability, making it a top choice for sustainability-conscious shoppers. On the other hand, Brooklyn Bedding offers a wider variety of options, with multiple firmness levels and hybrid designs to accommodate different sleep preferences at a more affordable price.

Ready to Buy? Here’s a Budget-Friendly Recommendation for You!

If you’re still unsure which mattress is the right fit for you, we’ve got some budget-friendly options that may catch your eye. Here are three excellent mattresses to consider:

Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress

A great choice for those looking for a comfortable, affordable memory foam mattress with pressure-relieving properties. It’s perfect for side sleepers and those on a budget.

Linenspa 8-Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress

This hybrid option offers a balanced feel, combining the support of innersprings with the comfort of memory foam. It’s a budget-friendly choice without compromising quality.

Tuft & Needle Original Mattress

Known for its high-quality construction at an affordable price, the Tuft & Needle mattress offers a simple, yet effective, design for back and stomach sleepers.

FAQs

Which is better for back sleepers: Avocado or Brooklyn Bedding?

For back sleepers, both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding offer great options. However, Avocado’s Green Mattress is known for its firmer support, making it a better option for back sleepers who need spinal alignment and extra support. Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid also works well, as it provides a balance of comfort and support with its combination of memory foam and pocketed coils, offering a medium to firm feel that is perfect for back sleepers.

Is Avocado’s mattress really eco-friendly?

Yes, Avocado’s mattresses are made from organic, certified materials, including organic latex, wool, and cotton. Their commitment to sustainability makes them a top choice for eco-conscious buyers. They also use natural fire retardants and avoid harmful chemicals in the production process. If you’re looking for an eco-friendly mattress that prioritizes both comfort and environmental impact, Avocado is an excellent option.

How long does it take to break in a Brooklyn Bedding mattress?

It generally takes around 30 days to fully break in a Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid or other similar models. During this period, the mattress will soften slightly, and the foam layers will adapt to your body. Some customers may notice that the mattress feels firmer initially, but after a month of use, it becomes more comfortable and supportive.

Can I try an Avocado mattress before purchasing?

Yes, Avocado offers a 100-night sleep trial. This allows you to test the mattress in your home and decide if it’s the right fit. If you’re not satisfied, you can return the mattress for a full refund. They also have a unique policy of donating returned mattresses to those in need, which aligns with their commitment to sustainability.

What’s the warranty on Brooklyn Bedding mattresses?

Brooklyn Bedding offers a 10-year warranty on their mattresses. This warranty covers defects in workmanship and materials. While it’s shorter than Avocado’s 25-year warranty, it still provides ample peace of mind, especially considering Brooklyn Bedding’s solid reputation for quality.

Which mattress is better for couples: Avocado or Brooklyn Bedding?

Both Avocado and Brooklyn Bedding offer great mattresses for couples, but Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid stands out due to its excellent motion isolation properties. The individually pocketed coils help minimize motion transfer, ensuring that one partner’s movements won’t disturb the other. Avocado also offers good motion isolation but is generally firmer, so it might be better suited for couples who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.