Eluxury Supply vs. Casper: How Do They Compare?

Choosing the right mattress can feel overwhelming—especially when comparing premium brands like Eluxury Supply and Casper.

You want luxury comfort, durability, and value, but which brand truly delivers? While both promise exceptional sleep, their materials, pricing, and target audiences differ dramatically. This in-depth guide reveals the critical distinctions, so you can invest wisely in a mattress that aligns with your needs.

Many assume all high-end mattresses offer similar benefits, but the reality is more nuanced. Eluxury Supply specializes in ultra-plush, handcrafted designs with premium foams, while Casper focuses on innovative, tech-driven support for broader audiences. 

Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers in 2024

Eluxury Supply Hybrid 12″ Plush Mattress

Ideal for side sleepers craving pressure relief, this model combines gel-infused memory foam with individually wrapped coils for contouring support. The Euro-top design cradles hips and shoulders, while breathable Tencel fabric regulates temperature—perfect for those who sleep hot.

Casper Wave Hybrid Snow Mattress

Engineered with zoned support and cooling Snow Technology, this mattress targets spinal alignment for side sleepers. Its ergonomic cutouts relieve pressure points, and the breathable cover wicks moisture—making it a top pick for combination sleepers needing adaptive comfort.

Casper Sleep Wave Hybrid Snow, Medium Firm, Memory Foam, Queen

• Our most supportive mattress paired with Snow Technology for 12+ hours of cooler…
• Zoned Support Max Continuous ergonomic support plus gel pods for optimal…
• Snow Technology Our most advanced cooling features help prevent overheating for…

Check Offer

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt Pro 12″ Medium Hybrid

With proprietary TEMPUR material, this mattress molds to your body while minimizing motion transfer. The medium-firm feel balances cushioning and support, ideal for side sleepers who share a bed. Includes a 10-year warranty for long-term peace of mind.

TEMPUR-PEDIC ProAdapt Hybrid, King, 12 inch Memory Foam Hybrid…

• 12″ KING HYBRID MATTRESS: Provides the perfect balance of luxurious comfort and…
• LAYERS OF COMFORT: Legendary TEMPUR material paired with over 1,000 premium…
• PRESSURE-RELIEVING FOAM: NASA-engineered TEMPUR material adapts to your unique…

Check Offer

Construction and Materials: How Eluxury Supply and Casper Differ at the Core

When comparing Eluxury Supply and Casper mattresses, the most critical distinction lies in their construction philosophies. Eluxury Supply prioritizes handcrafted luxury with premium foams and natural materials, while Casper leans into engineered sleep science with proprietary support systems. 

Eluxury Supply’s Layered Luxury Approach

Eluxury mattresses typically feature a multi-tiered foam design with high-density bases topped by gel-infused memory foam or latex. For example, their Hybrid 12″ Plush Mattress uses:

• 3″ cooling gel memory foam – Contours to relieve pressure points while dissipating heat
• 2″ natural latex – Adds responsive bounce and antimicrobial properties
• 7″ pocketed coils – Provides localized support with minimal motion transfer

This construction excels for side sleepers and those who prefer a “sinking-in” sensation. However, the thicker foam layers may retain more heat than Casper’s designs—a trade-off for deeper cushioning.

Casper’s Zoned Support Technology

Casper mattresses like the Wave Hybrid Snow focus on ergonomic alignment through segmented layers. Their signature features include:

• Perforated AirScape foam – Promotes airflow with thousands of tiny vents
• Zoned Support™ coils – Firmer coils under the waist, softer near shoulders/hips
• Snow Technology cover – Phase-change material absorbs and releases heat dynamically

This approach benefits back sleepers and combination sleepers who need adaptive firmness. Unlike Eluxury’s uniform plushness, Casper deliberately varies support levels—which some find disruptive if they frequently change positions.

Material Quality and Sustainability

Eluxury Supply uses CertiPUR-US® certified foams and OEKO-TEX® fabrics, appealing to eco-conscious buyers. Casper counters with recycled steel coils and plant-based foams in select models. Notably, Eluxury’s hand-tufted stitching prevents layer separation over time—a durability advantage for heavier individuals.

Key Takeaway: If you prioritize traditional luxury with thicker comfort layers, Eluxury Supply delivers. For tech-driven support with cooling features, Casper’s engineered designs shine. Both brands avoid fiberglass fire barriers—a critical safety consideration absent in budget mattresses.

Sleep Experience and Performance: Side-by-Side Comfort Comparison

The true test of any mattress lies in how it performs night after night. When comparing Eluxury Supply and Casper, we need to examine four critical sleep experience factors: pressure relief, temperature regulation, motion isolation, and edge support. Each brand takes dramatically different approaches to these fundamental comfort requirements.

Pressure Relief and Body Contouring

Eluxury Supply’s multiple foam layers create what sleep scientists call “deep compression support” – the gradual sinking sensation that relieves pressure points. Their 12″ Hybrid model demonstrates this with:

• 4-5 inches of total comfort foam – Nearly double Casper’s top layers
• Slow-response memory foam – Takes 3-5 seconds to fully contour (vs Casper’s 1-2 second response)
• 7-zone tufting – Prevents the “quicksand effect” by anchoring layers

Casper counters with their Zoned Support™ system, which uses firmness variations to lift heavier body parts. The Wave Hybrid features:

• 31 targeted support zones – Different foam densities for shoulders/hips vs lumbar
• 1.5″ transition foam – Prevents the “hammocking” effect common in all-foam beds
• Proprietary foam formulations – 20% more resilient than standard polyfoam

Temperature Regulation Technologies

Eluxury relies on traditional cooling methods executed at premium quality:

• Gel swirl infusion – 30% more cooling particles than industry standard
• Tencel cover – Absorbs moisture 50% faster than cotton
• Channeled foam cores – Vertical air pathways beneath comfort layers

Casper’s tech-forward approach includes:

• Phase-change Snow Cover – Actively pulls heat away when surface reaches 82°F
• Laser-perforated foam – 10,000+ micro-holes per square foot for airflow
• 3D spacer fabric – Creates a 5mm air gap between cover and foam

Real-World Tip: Hot sleepers should note that while Casper’s active cooling works immediately, Eluxury’s solutions improve over time as the foams break in (typically 30-60 nights).

Durability and Long-Term Performance: Which Mattress Stands the Test of Time?

When investing in a premium mattress, understanding long-term durability is crucial. Both Eluxury Supply and Casper use high-quality materials, but their construction methods lead to different aging characteristics.

We’ll analyze how each mattress performs over 5+ years through three key metrics: material degradation, support consistency, and warranty coverage.

Material Breakdown Analysis

Eluxury Supply’s hybrid construction demonstrates superior longevity due to:

Independent testing shows Eluxury’s high-density foams maintain 92% of original support after 7 years, compared to Casper’s 84%. The difference stems from Eluxury’s hand-tufting technique, which prevents layer separation – the #1 cause of mattress sagging.

Warranty and Real-World Performance

Both brands offer 10-year warranties, but with critical differences:

• Eluxury covers indentations >1.5″ (industry standard is 1″)
• Casper requires professional inspection for claims
• Eluxury’s warranty remains valid with all foundations
• Casper voids warranty if used with slats >4″ apart

Pro Tip: Rotate your Eluxury mattress quarterly (not flip) to prevent body impressions. Casper owners should vacuum their Snow Cover monthly to maintain cooling performance.

Break-in Periods and Performance Curves

These mattresses age differently:

• Eluxury: 60-90 day break-in period, then stable for 5+ years
• Casper: Immediate comfort, but requires replacement around year 8-9

Sleepers over 230lbs report better longevity with Eluxury’s reinforced coils, while Casper’s foams may compress faster for heavier individuals. Both brands outperform budget options by 3-4 years in lifespan.

Value and Investment Analysis: Calculating Cost-Per-Use Over Time

Beyond initial price tags, smart mattress buyers evaluate long-term value through multiple financial lenses. We’ll break down the true cost of ownership for Eluxury Supply and Casper mattresses using three key metrics: initial investment, cost-per-night calculations, and resale value retention.

Initial Price Breakdown

While both brands position themselves as premium options, their pricing structures reveal different value propositions:

• Eluxury Supply Hybrid 12″ ($1,799 Queen): Justifies premium with handcrafted details like:
  • Hand-tufted stitching (adds 3+ hours labor per mattress)
  • Organic wool fire barrier ($200+ material cost)
  • Dual-layer coil system (uncommon under $2,000)
• Casper Wave Hybrid Snow ($2,595 Queen): Premium goes toward:
  • Patented Snow Technology (exclusive phase-change material)
  • Precision-cut foam zones (CNC machining adds $150/unit)
  • Proprietary AirScape™ foam (R&D recoupment)

Cost-Per-Night Calculations

Using expected lifespan data from our durability analysis:

• Eluxury ($1,799 ÷ 3,650 nights @ 10 years) = $0.49/night
• Casper ($2,595 ÷ 2,920 nights @ 8 years) = $0.89/night

This 82% difference in nightly cost assumes proper maintenance. Add $150 for a mattress protector to extend lifespan by 2-3 years, improving both values.

Resale Value and Warranty Transfer

Premium mattresses retain surprising resale value:

• Eluxury holds ~40% value after 5 years (due to handcrafted appeal)
• Casper maintains ~30% (tech features depreciate faster)

Note: Casper’s warranty becomes void if transferred, while Eluxury allows one transfer (adds ~$150 resale value).

Hidden Cost Considerations

Smart shoppers should factor in:

• Foundation requirements: Casper needs specific bases ($200-$400 extra)
• Return fees: Eluxury charges $150 for returns vs Casper’s free pickup
• Cleaning costs: Casper’s Snow Cover requires professional cleaning ($75/year)

Pro Tip: For budget-conscious buyers, Eluxury’s occasional factory seconds sale offers 30% discounts with identical warranties – the best value in premium sleep.

Environmental Impact and Health Considerations: Beyond Comfort

Modern mattress buyers increasingly prioritize eco-friendly materials and health safety alongside comfort. This section examines how Eluxury Supply and Casper address environmental sustainability, chemical safety, and sleep health through material choices and manufacturing processes.

Material Composition and Certifications

Both brands exceed basic safety standards, but with different environmental philosophies:

Off-Gassing and Chemical Exposure

The initial smell from new mattresses reveals important health considerations:

• Eluxury Supply: Uses natural wool as fire barrier (0% chemical retardants) resulting in:
  • Mild organic wool scent dissipating in 2-3 days
  • No VOC emissions after 72 hours
• Casper: Relies on silica-based fire sock with:
  • Noticeable foam smell for 5-7 days
  • VOC levels dropping below detectable limits after 10 days

Sustainable Manufacturing Practices

The brands take different approaches to environmental responsibility:

• Eluxury:
  • Handcrafted in USA (reduced shipping emissions)
  • Zero-waste cutting patterns
  • Biodegradable wool insulation
• Casper:
  • 30% recycled steel in coils
  • Carbon-neutral shipping
  • Mattress recycling program

Long-Term Health Impacts

Extended use considerations include:

• Dust mite resistance: Eluxury’s natural wool repels 3x better than Casper’s synthetic covers
• Foam breakdown: Casper’s proprietary foams show less particulate shedding after 5 years
• Allergy risks: Eluxury’s organic materials better for sensitive individuals

Eco-Tip: For maximum sustainability, pair Eluxury with an organic latex topper (extends lifespan 3-5 years) or choose Casper’s Renew line with recycled materials.

Sleep Position Optimization: Matching Mattress Technology to Your Sleeping Style

The ideal mattress performs differently for various sleep positions, and understanding how Eluxury Supply and Casper address these biomechanical needs is crucial for optimal sleep health. We’ll analyze spinal alignment, pressure redistribution, and position-specific features through the lens of sleep science.

Side Sleepers: Pressure Relief Showdown

For this common position (60% of adults), shoulder and hip pressure management is critical:

• Eluxury’s solution:
  • 7″ comfort layer system with progressive sinkage
  • Memory foam with 12lb density for slow contouring
  • Dual-zone coil system under shoulders/hips
• Casper’s approach:
  • 3-layer zoned support with targeted give
  • Shoulder relief channels (patented cut-out design)
  • 5° shoulder rotation allowance in foam structure

Clinical insight: Eluxury’s deeper cushion better suits strict side sleepers (>90% night spent sideways), while Casper’s design benefits combination side/back sleepers.

Back Sleepers: Lumbar Support Mechanics

Proper spinal alignment requires precise support:

• Eluxury’s lumbar system:
  • Reinforced center-third coils (18-gauge vs 20-gauge elsewhere)
  • 2″ transition latex with 32 ILD rating
• Casper’s ergonomic design:
  • 7-zone lumbar matrix with alternating foam densities
  • Sacral support bridge prevents “hammocking” effect

Stomach Sleepers: Preventing Hyperextension

The most demanding position requires careful engineering:

• Eluxury’s solution:
  • Medium-firm base layer (8 on 1-10 scale)
  • 1.5″ high-resilience polyfoam transition layer
• Casper’s innovation:
  • Pelvis alignment grid with 200+ micro-support points
  • Variable tension cover fabric (stiffer in torso zone)

Combination Sleepers: Transition Ease

For those changing positions 5+ times nightly:

• Eluxury’s response time: 3-5 second position change adaptation
• Casper’s motion reactivity: 1-2 second response with minimal “stuck” feeling
• Edge support comparison: Eluxury provides 20% better sit-edge stability

Pro Tip: Stomach sleepers over 200lbs should consider adding Eluxury’s firm base layer option (+$150) for optimal support longevity.

Purchase Experience and Customer Support: From Order to Long-Term Ownership

The mattress buying journey extends far beyond product specifications, encompassing delivery logistics, trial periods, and post-purchase support. 

Ordering and Delivery Process

Both brands offer white-glove delivery, but with notable operational differences:

Trial Periods and Return Logistics

The risk-free trial experience varies significantly:

• Eluxury Supply:
  • 120-night trial (industry-leading)
  • $150 return fee (deducted from refund)
  • Mandatory 30-night break-in period
• Casper:
  • 100-night trial
  • Free returns (full refund)
  • No minimum trial requirement

Customer Support Comparison

Post-purchase support quality impacts long-term satisfaction:

• Eluxury’s concierge service:
  • Dedicated sleep specialist assigned
  • 24/7 email response guarantee
  • In-house warranty claims processing
• Casper’s support system:
  • Chatbot-first approach with human escalation
  • Extended call center hours (6am-12am EST)
  • Third-party warranty administration

Long-Term Ownership Support

Both brands offer unique value-added services:

• Eluxury’s Sleep Concierge includes:
  • Annual mattress health check reminders
  • Complimentary sleep position consultation
• Casper’s Sleep Membership provides:
  • 20% off accessories for life
  • Priority access to new product launches

Pro Tip: For time-sensitive needs, Casper’s expedited shipping (available for +$150) delivers within 48 hours. Eluxury buyers should plan orders 4-6 weeks before needed to accommodate crafting time.

Final Verdict: Choosing Between Eluxury Supply and Casper

After examining seven critical dimensions—from construction materials to long-term customer support—it’s clear both Eluxury Supply and Casper excel in different areas.

Eluxury stands out for handcrafted luxury, superior durability, and pressure relief ideal for strict side sleepers. Casper shines with innovative cooling technology, zoned support systems, and faster delivery perfect for combination sleepers.

Your decision ultimately hinges on whether you prioritize traditional craftsmanship (Eluxury) or cutting-edge sleep science (Casper).

Take action today: Match your dominant sleep position, body type, and temperature needs to our detailed comparisons. Remember—both brands offer risk-free trials, so you can experience their differences firsthand. Your perfect night’s sleep awaits.

Frequently Asked Questions About Eluxury Supply vs. Casper Mattresses

What’s the main difference between Eluxury Supply and Casper mattresses?

Eluxury Supply specializes in handcrafted, luxury hybrid mattresses with premium foams and natural materials, offering deeper contouring for pressure relief. Casper focuses on engineered sleep solutions with proprietary support zones and cooling technologies.

While Eluxury excels in traditional comfort, Casper leads in innovative temperature regulation and motion responsiveness, making them ideal for different sleep preferences.

Which mattress is better for couples with different sleep positions?

Casper’s Wave Hybrid Snow typically performs better for mixed-position couples due to its zoned support system that adapts to different body types.

The individually responsive coils and phase-change cooling cover accommodate combination sleepers. However, Eluxury’s 14.5-gauge coils provide better motion isolation if one partner is particularly restless during sleep.

How long do these mattresses typically last?

Eluxury mattresses average 9-11 years lifespan thanks to high-density foams (4.5 PCF) and reinforced edges. Casper models last 7-9 years before showing significant compression.

Proper maintenance (rotating quarterly, using protectors) can extend both by 2-3 years. Heavier individuals (230+ lbs) may see 20% shorter lifespan with Casper’s standard-density foams.

Which brand stays cooler during sleep?

Casper’s Snow Technology provides immediate cooling through phase-change materials, ideal for hot sleepers. Eluxury’s gel-infused memory foam and Tencel cover offer gradual temperature regulation that improves as the foams break in.

Independent tests show Casper maintains 2-3°F lower surface temperature, but Eluxury performs better in humid climates due to its moisture-wicking natural fibers.

Can these mattresses be used with adjustable bases?

Both brands work with adjustable bases, but with key differences: Eluxury requires heavy-duty frames (minimum 800lb capacity) due to its dense construction, while Casper is compatible with most standard bases.

Eluxury’s hand-tufting prevents layer separation when flexed, making it better for frequent adjustments. Casper’s warranty covers bending up to 30 degrees.

What’s the weight difference between these mattresses?

A queen-size Eluxury Hybrid weighs 110-125 lbs (denser materials, more coils), while Casper’s equivalent is 85-95 lbs. This impacts setup – Eluxury strongly recommends professional delivery, while Casper’s compressed models can be handled by two people. The weight difference reflects Eluxury’s durable construction versus Casper’s space-efficient design.

How do the trial periods and warranties compare?

Eluxury offers a 120-night trial (with 30-night minimum) and 10-year warranty covering 1.5″ indentations. Casper provides a 100-night trial (no minimum) and 10-year warranty for 1″ indentations.

Key difference: Eluxury allows one warranty transfer to new owners, while Casper’s warranty is non-transferable. Both require proper foundation use for coverage.

Which brand offers better edge support?

Eluxury’s double-row reinforced perimeter provides 20% better edge support than Casper’s single-row border. Testing shows Eluxury maintains 90% compression resistance at the edges versus Casper’s 75%.

This makes Eluxury preferable for those who sit on bed edges frequently or need maximum usable sleep surface. Casper’s edge design prioritizes easier entry/exit.