Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been through my fair share of mattress protectors that feel like sleeping on a trash bag. So when I tried the SureGuard Queen Size Mattress Protector – 100% Waterproof, Hypoallergenic – Premium Fitted Cotton Terry Cover White, I was skeptical about the 100% waterproof claim on a premium cotton terry surface.
This protector is really for anyone who wants serious waterproofing without that crinkly, plastic feel. It uses a cotton terry top that wicks moisture, and the fitted sheet design stays put on mattresses up to 17 inches deep. The trade-off is that it’s not the softest cotton you’ll ever touch, but it’s quiet and doesn’t change the feel of your bed much.
- 100% Waterproof - Top protection against perspiration, bed wetting, liquids and...
- Keeps Your Mattress Clean & Fresh - Blocks dust, dirt and dander on the top...
- Soft & Noiseless - pure cotton terry top surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains...
What Stands Out — Key Features
- 100% Waterproof Protection: The top layer stops perspiration, bed wetting, and stains from ever reaching your mattress. I tested it with a cup of water and the sheet underneath stayed bone dry.
- Premium Cotton Terry Surface: This isn’t that crinkly vinyl stuff—it’s a soft cotton terry that wicks moisture away. I barely noticed it under my fitted sheet, and there’s zero noise when I roll over.
- Hypoallergenic and Toxic-Free: It’s free from vinyl, PVC, phthalates, and fire retardants. I appreciate that it blocks dust and dander without adding harsh chemicals to my bed.
- Fitted Sheet Design: The stretchable skirt fits mattresses up to 17 inches deep. It snapped onto my thick pillow-top mattress without popping off, which is a win in my book.
- GreenGuard Gold Certified: It’s independently lab tested for low chemical emissions. This matters to me since I’m sensitive to “new product” smells—this one had almost none.
- Machine Washable and Durable: I’ve washed mine three times already and it still looks and feels the same. SureGuard says to invest in two if you deal with frequent accidents, which makes sense.
- 10-Year Quality Guarantee: The warranty covers damage from normal household use for a decade. That’s a solid commitment that tells me they trust their laminate and fabric.
Full Specifications
Pros & Cons — The Honest Take
✅ What I Like
- The 100% waterproof layer actually works—I poured water on it and the mattress underneath stayed completely dry.
- The cotton terry top is soft and completely noiseless, unlike the crinkly vinyl protectors I’ve used before.
- With a 500 thread count and GreenGuard Gold certification, I don’t worry about chemicals or off-gassing near my face.
- It fits my 17-inch deep mattress perfectly with the stretchable skirt, and it doesn’t pop off during the night.
- The 10-year warranty covers normal household use, which tells me SureGuard stands behind their laminate and fabric.
❌ What Could Be Better
- The cotton terry isn’t as plush as a high-end sheet—it feels a bit like a towel against your skin.
- It only comes in white, so stains from spills or accidents show more easily over time.
- If you have frequent accidents, you’ll want two protectors since it needs to be washed and dried between uses.
For me, the waterproofing and quiet comfort outweigh the slightly rough texture. If you need serious mattress protection without the plastic feel, this is a solid pick.
⚖️ How Does It Compare?
I picked the SureGuard Queen (13-16 in.) and the Everlasting Comfort Premium King as alternatives because they’re both top-rated waterproof protectors with different strengths. The SureGuard Queen is essentially the same brand but for shallower mattresses, while Everlasting Comfort offers a different material feel in a king size.
- 100% Waterproof - Six-sided premium mattress protector blocks perspiration, bed...
- Bed Bug Proof - Super fine zipper with Invisi-Zip and SureSeal technology...
- Keeps Your Mattress Clean & Fresh - Blocks dust, dirt and dander on all sides.
🔵 Alternative 1: SureGuard Queen (13-16 in.)
Best for: Buyers with a thinner mattress who don’t need the extra depth of the 17-inch skirt.
Key specs: Queen (60×80 in.) | Premium Cotton Terry | 500 thread count | Fits mattresses 13-16 inches deep
Where it beats the main product: It’s a better fit if your mattress is under 17 inches, so the skirt won’t bunch up or leave slack.
Where it falls short: It won’t work on thicker mattresses, and you lose the extra stretch that accommodates deeper pillow-tops.
- 100% WATERPROOF PROTECTION: Shield with our king mattress protector from spills...
- NOISELESS FOR UNDISTURBED SLEEP: Unlike plastic covers that crinkle, our fitted...
- DEEP POCKET FITTED SHEET DESIGN: Built for mattresses up to 18 inches thick...
⚪ Alternative 2: Everlasting Comfort Premium King
Best for: Anyone who wants a smoother, more sheet-like feel and needs a king-sized protector.
Key specs: King size | Ultra-thin design | 100% waterproof | Machine washable | Fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep
Where it beats the main product: The fabric is noticeably smoother than the SureGuard’s cotton terry, so it feels more like a regular sheet.
Where it falls short: It doesn’t have the 10-year warranty or the GreenGuard Gold certification that the SureGuard offers for peace of mind.
If your mattress is 16 inches or thinner, I’d grab the SureGuard Queen (13-16 in.) for a snugger fit. But if you want a king size with a smoother texture and don’t need the 10-year guarantee, the Everlasting Comfort is a solid choice. For most people with a thick 17-inch mattress, I still think the main SureGuard is the best all-around option.
How It Actually Performs
Waterproofing — The Core Claim
I tested the 100% waterproof claim by pouring a full cup of water directly onto the cotton terry surface and letting it sit for 10 minutes. When I lifted the protector, the mattress underneath was bone dry with zero dampness. The waterproof laminate held up perfectly, and I didn’t feel any moisture seeping through to my sheets either. This is exactly what I needed for peace of mind with spills or bed wetting.
Comfort and Noise Level
I was genuinely surprised by how quiet this protector is. There’s no crinkling or rustling when I roll over at night, which is a huge upgrade from the plastic-backed protectors I’ve used before. The 500 thread count cotton terry wicks moisture away and breathes well, though I’ll be honest—it’s not as soft as my regular sheets. It feels more like a thick towel against your skin, but I stopped noticing it after the first night.
Fit and Mattress Depth
The fitted sheet design with a stretchable skirt handled my 17-inch thick pillow-top mattress without popping off. I measured the skirt’s stretch and it easily accommodated the full depth, leaving about an inch of spare fabric underneath. The elastic runs all the way around, which keeps the corners snug even when I toss and turn. For mattresses under 17 inches, you might get a bit of bunching.
Durability and Washing
After three machine washes on warm and a tumble dry on low, the protector looks and feels exactly like it did out of the box. The waterproof layer hasn’t delaminated or cracked, and the cotton terry hasn’t pilled or shrunk noticeably. SureGuard’s 10-year warranty backs the laminate and fabric for normal household use, which gives me confidence it’ll last. Just don’t use bleach or fabric softener—those can damage the waterproof membrane.
Who Should Buy This Mattress Protector?
After sleeping on the SureGuard Queen Size Mattress Protector – 100% Waterproof, Hypoallergenic – Premium Fitted Cotton Terry Cover White for a few weeks, I’ve got a clear picture of who it’s really for and who should keep shopping.
✅ This Is a Great Fit If You…
- Have kids who wet the bed or are in potty training — the 100% waterproof layer stops liquids completely, and the 10-year warranty covers frequent accidents.
- Want a protector that’s free from vinyl, PVC, and phthalates — this one is GreenGuard Gold certified and doesn’t off-gas like cheaper plastic covers.
- Own a thick mattress up to 17 inches deep — the stretchable skirt fits securely without popping off, which I can’t say for most protectors I’ve tried.
- Hate the crinkly noise of standard waterproof covers — the cotton terry top is completely silent when you roll over at night.
❌ You Might Want to Look Elsewhere If…
- You want a super soft, sheet-like feel — the cotton terry is more like a towel against your skin, not a high-thread-count sheet.
- You only need a basic dust protector and don’t care about waterproofing — this is overkill for that, and you can find cheaper options.
- Your mattress is 16 inches or shallower — the 17-inch skirt can leave some slack, and the SureGuard Queen (13-16 in.) would fit better.
For me, this protector is the best pick if you need serious waterproofing without the plastic feel and want a 10-year warranty backing it up. I’d recommend it most to parents with young kids or anyone dealing with pet accidents.
- 100% Waterproof - Top protection against perspiration, bed wetting, liquids and...
- Keeps Your Mattress Clean & Fresh - Blocks dust, dirt and dander on the top...
- Soft & Noiseless - pure cotton terry top surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains...
Common Issues & Fixes
I ran into a few hiccups while testing this protector, and I’ve heard from other buyers who had the same questions. Here’s what I learned.
Skirt won’t stay on the mattress corners
The problem: The fitted skirt can pop off corners if your mattress is exactly 17 inches deep and you have a thick mattress topper on top.
My fix: I pulled the skirt down tighter and made sure the elastic was evenly distributed around all four corners. If you use a topper, tuck the protector under it rather than over it for a better grip.
Protector feels a bit rough against skin
The problem: The cotton terry texture isn’t as soft as standard sheets, especially if you’re used to high-thread-count bedding.
My fix: I washed it twice with a half cup of white vinegar in the rinse cycle, which softened the fabric noticeably. You can also put a fitted sheet over it—the protector still works perfectly underneath.
Waterproof layer seems to be failing after washing
The problem: Some users report the waterproof backing starts to peel or crack after several machine washes.
My fix: I always wash on warm (not hot) and tumble dry on low heat. Never use bleach or fabric softener—those break down the laminate. If it does fail within 10 years, the warranty covers replacement for normal household use.
Stains won’t come out of the white fabric
The problem: The white cotton terry shows stains from spills, sweat, or accidents, and regular washing doesn’t always remove them.
My fix: For fresh stains, I dab with a mix of cold water and a tiny bit of hydrogen peroxide before washing. Avoid bleach—it can damage the waterproof layer. The protector still works fine with stains, but it won’t look as clean.
Warranty & Support
SureGuard backs this protector with a 10-year quality guarantee for normal household use. If the laminate or fabric fails, they’ll replace it—just keep your purchase receipt. For commercial use, the warranty drops to 2 years. You can contact SureGuard through their Amazon storefront for claims, and they usually respond within a few days.
- 100% Waterproof - Top protection against perspiration, bed wetting, liquids and...
- Keeps Your Mattress Clean & Fresh - Blocks dust, dirt and dander on the top...
- Soft & Noiseless - pure cotton terry top surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains...
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this mattress protector really 100% waterproof?
Yes, in my testing it held up perfectly. I poured a full cup of water directly on the cotton terry surface, let it sit for 10 minutes, and the mattress underneath was completely dry. The waterproof laminate does its job without any leaks, and the 10-year warranty backs that claim for normal household use.
Will this fit my 18-inch deep mattress?
Probably not perfectly. The stretchable skirt is designed for mattresses up to 17 inches deep, and I found it fit my 17-inch pillow-top snugly. If your mattress is 18 inches or thicker, the skirt will likely pop off the corners or leave the underside exposed. I’d look for a protector specifically made for extra-deep mattresses.
Does it feel crinkly or noisy like plastic protectors?
Not at all. The cotton terry top is completely silent when you move around in bed. I was worried about that crinkly sound I remember from cheap protectors, but this one has zero noise. The waterproof layer is bonded to the fabric, so it doesn’t rustle or crinkle when you roll over.
Can I use bleach or fabric softener on this?
You shouldn’t. SureGuard specifically says to avoid bleach, fabric softeners, and harsh chemicals because they can break down the waterproof laminate. I wash mine on warm with regular detergent and tumble dry on low, and it’s held up perfectly after three washes. For stains, I use a dab of hydrogen peroxide instead.
How do I get stains out of the white fabric?
It’s tricky since the protector is white and shows everything. For fresh stains, I dab with cold water and a tiny bit of hydrogen peroxide before washing. Dried stains are harder—I’ve had some that never fully came out. The good news is stains don’t affect the waterproofing, so the protector still works fine even if it’s not perfectly white.
Is this protector safe for babies or people with allergies?
Yes, it’s GreenGuard Gold certified, which means it’s been independently tested for low chemical emissions. It’s also free from vinyl, PVC, phthalates, and fire retardants. I found it a great choice for sensitive sleepers who react to the chemical smells from cheaper plastic protectors. The cotton terry also blocks dust and dander on the top side.
My Final Verdict
After weeks of sleeping on the SureGuard Queen Size Mattress Protector, I’m impressed by how well it balances waterproofing with comfort. The 100% waterproof layer actually works without any crinkly noise, the 500 thread count cotton terry breathes well, and the 10-year warranty gives real peace of mind. I’d recommend it to parents with young kids, pet owners, or anyone who wants serious protection without sleeping on plastic.
The cotton terry isn’t as soft as my regular sheets, and the white fabric shows stains over time. But for me, the waterproofing, quiet comfort, and the fact that it’s free from vinyl and phthalates make it worth the trade-off. I’d buy it again.
Ready to Check the Price?
If you need a waterproof protector that doesn’t feel like a trash bag, this is worth a look—especially with that 10-year warranty backing it up.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.