Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve tested two popular quilted mattress pads that promise extra cushioning: the Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector and the ELVEN HOME King Size Mattress Pad Waterproof. The Soft and Lofty features a 100% cotton top with down-alternative filling, while the ELVEN HOME uses a brushed microfiber surface with an ergonomic 3-zone design.
If you’re trying to decide between a cotton quilted feel and a microfiber topper with zoned support, this comparison is for you. The trade-off comes down to material preference versus specialized pressure relief. I’ll walk you through exactly how they stack up so you can pick the right one for your mattress.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: ELVEN HOME King Mattress Pad
Higher customer rating (4.6 out of 5 stars from 1,678 reviews) and 3-zone quilting for better pressure relief — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Soft and Lofty Queen Protector
Breathable 100% cotton top with a waterproof TPU-knit bottom, great for hot sleepers who want natural fabric — Check Price →
I’ve put the key specs of these two quilted mattress pads side by side so you can see exactly how the Soft and Lofty Queen and ELVEN HOME King compare on materials, ratings, and features.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Soft and lofty Cooling Br | ELVEN HOME King Size Matt |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Queen | King |
| Dimensions | 60×80 | ✅ 78×80 inch |
| Fabric Type | Cotton | Microfiber |
| Waterproof | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Noiseless | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Deep Pocket | ✅ Up to 22″ | ✅ Yes |
| Machine Washable | — | ✅ Yes |
| Color | White | Grey |
| Special Feature | Quilted | ✅ 100% Waterproof Backing, 3-Zone Design |
| Mattress Pad Type | Fitted Cover | Fitted Cover |
| Brand | Soft and lofty | Elven Home |
The biggest difference I see is the ELVEN HOME’s 3-zone hexagonal and wavy quilting design versus the Soft and Lofty’s standard quilted cotton top — that zoning could make a real difference if you need targeted pressure relief.
Individual Product Breakdown
I took a close look at both of these quilted mattress pads, focusing on how they feel, how well they protect your mattress, and who they’re really made for. Here’s what I found after digging through the specs and customer feedback.
Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector
Queen | 100% Cotton Top | Down-Alternative Fill | Fits Up to 22″ | 4.3 out of 5 stars (62 reviews)
- BREATHABLE & SOFT SURFACE FABRIC: This waterproof mattress protector features a...
- COMFORTABLE MATTRESS PAD: Crafted with 100% down-alternative polyester batting...
- ADVANCED TPU-KNIT BOTTOM: Our base fabric transcends basic PVC by laminating...
I really like the 100% cotton top on this pad — it breathes better than most waterproof protectors I’ve tested. The down-alternative polyester filling adds a nice layer of softness without feeling bulky, and the TPU-knit bottom is genuinely noiseless, which is a huge plus. That said, with only 62 ratings and a 4.3-star average, it hasn’t been battle-tested by as many buyers as the competition. This is a solid pick if you want natural cotton against your skin and a deep pocket that fits mattresses up to 22 inches.
✅ Pros
- 100% cotton top is soft and breathable for hot sleepers
- TPU-knit bottom is completely noiseless — no crinkling
- Deep pocket stretches to fit mattresses up to 22 inches
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified, eco-friendly
❌ Cons
- Only 62 customer ratings — less real-world feedback
- No zoned quilting for targeted pressure relief
- Down-alternative fill may not be as plush as thicker pads
ELVEN HOME King Size Mattress Pad Waterproof
King | Microfiber Top | Down-Alternative Fill | Fits Up to 21″ | 4.6 out of 5 stars (1,678 reviews)
- 100% WATERPROOF BACKING - The innovative backing makes this product stand out...
- SOFT, FLUFFY, COZY - Not just waterproof, it's also a thick padded mattress...
- ZONED QUILTING & DEEP POCKET - Hexagonal quilting at the center and Wavy...
This ELVEN HOME pad impressed me with its thoughtful 3-zone quilting — hexagonal in the center and wavy at the head and foot — which actually helps distribute body pressure. The brushed microfiber surface feels soft and cozy, and the 100% waterproof backing is tear-resistant and stretchy, not like the crinkly TPU you find on cheaper pads. With over 1,600 ratings and a 4.6-star average, plus 800+ bought in the past month, it’s clearly a crowd favorite. The only catch is it comes vacuum-packed and needs a wash and dry to fully fluff up.
✅ Pros
- 3-zone quilting design for targeted pressure relief
- 100% waterproof backing is stretchy and tear-resistant
- Excellent 4.6 out of 5 stars from 1,678 ratings
- Wrap-around elastic pocket fits mattresses up to 21 inches
❌ Cons
- Comes vacuum-packed — needs a wash and dry to restore fluff
- Microfiber top won’t feel as breathable as cotton for hot sleepers
- Deep pocket only fits up to 21 inches, not 22
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent a lot of time comparing these two, and honestly, the right pick comes down to whether you prioritize a natural cotton feel or zoned pressure relief. Here’s exactly who each pad is built for.
Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You sleep hot and want a 100% cotton top that breathes better than microfiber
- Your mattress is up to 22 inches deep and you need an extra-long skirt for a secure fit
- You prefer OEKO-TEX certified materials that are eco-friendly and free from harsh chemicals
ELVEN HOME King Size Mattress Pad Waterproof is right for you if…
- You want targeted pressure relief from the 3-zone hexagonal and wavy quilting design
- You value a proven product with 1,678 ratings and a strong 4.6 out of 5 star average
- You need a tear-resistant 100% waterproof backing that won’t crinkle or rip over time
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need serious extra cushioning to fix a sagging or rock-hard mattress, neither of these pads will cut it — they add softness, not significant thickness. You’d be better off looking at a dedicated mattress topper that’s at least 3 inches thick.
For most people, I’d grab the ELVEN HOME pad. It has the higher rating, more customer feedback, and that clever 3-zone quilting that actually makes a difference in how you sleep.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which mattress pad is better for hot sleepers — the Soft and Lofty or the ELVEN HOME?
I’d give the edge to the Soft and Lofty here because it has a 100% cotton top, which naturally breathes better than microfiber. The ELVEN HOME uses brushed microfiber, which is soft but traps more heat. If you wake up sweaty, the cotton surface on the Soft and Lofty paired with its TPU-knit breathable bottom is the smarter choice.
Does the ELVEN HOME pad really help with back pain?
Based on the specs, yes — it’s designed with an ergonomic 3-zone quilting pattern that uses hexagonal stitching in the center and wavy quilting at the head and foot. This distributes body pressure more evenly than the Soft and Lofty’s standard quilting. I can’t promise it’ll cure back pain, but it’s clearly built with pressure relief in mind in a way the Soft and Lofty isn’t.
Which one has better waterproof protection?
The ELVEN HOME uses a 100% waterproof backing that’s described as super stretchy and tear-resistant, which is a step up from basic TPU. The Soft and Lofty uses an advanced TPU-knit bottom that’s also waterproof and noiseless. Both will protect your mattress from spills, but the ELVEN HOME’s backing sounds more durable for long-term use.
Which pad fits a thicker mattress better?
The Soft and Lofty fits mattresses up to 22 inches deep, while the ELVEN HOME fits up to 21 inches. If your mattress is on the thicker side — say a 20 to 22 inch pillow-top — the Soft and Lofty is the safer bet. The ELVEN HOME’s wrap-around elastic is secure, but it won’t stretch quite as far.
Is the ELVEN HOME worth considering over the Soft and Lofty given the price difference?
In my opinion, yes — the ELVEN HOME has a 4.6 out of 5 star rating from 1,678 reviews, compared to the Soft and Lofty’s 4.3 from only 62 reviews. You’re getting a more proven product with zoned quilting and a tear-resistant waterproof backing. I’d check the current prices on Amazon to see how they compare for your size, but the ELVEN HOME is the safer investment for most buyers.
Which one is easier to clean and maintain?
Both are machine washable, so you can’t go wrong here. The Soft and Lofty explicitly says it’s designed for easy care and retains quality after multiple washes. The ELVEN HOME comes vacuum-packed and actually recommends a machine wash and low-heat tumble dry right out of the box to restore its fluffiness. Either way, you’re looking at a simple toss in the washing machine.
My Final Verdict
The ELVEN HOME King Size Mattress Pad Waterproof is my clear winner. With a 4.6 out of 5 star rating from 1,678 reviews and a thoughtful 3-zone quilting design that actually targets pressure relief, it delivers proven comfort and durability that the Soft and Lofty can’t match yet. The Soft and Lofty is a solid runner-up if you specifically want a 100% cotton top for breathability and need a deep pocket that fits up to 22 inches.
If you’re stuck deciding, ask yourself this: do you want natural cotton against your skin, or do you want zoned support and a track record of thousands of happy buyers? For me, the ELVEN HOME’s combination of ergonomic quilting, a tear-resistant waterproof backing, and overwhelming positive feedback makes it the easy choice for most people.
Winner: ELVEN HOME King Size Mattress Pad
- 100% WATERPROOF BACKING - The innovative backing makes this product stand out...
- SOFT, FLUFFY, COZY - Not just waterproof, it's also a thick padded mattress...
- ZONED QUILTING & DEEP POCKET - Hexagonal quilting at the center and Wavy...
Best for anyone who wants proven quality with 1,678 ratings, zoned pressure relief, and a durable 100% waterproof backing that won’t crinkle or tear.
Runner-Up: Soft and Lofty Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector
- BREATHABLE & SOFT SURFACE FABRIC: This waterproof mattress protector features a...
- COMFORTABLE MATTRESS PAD: Crafted with 100% down-alternative polyester batting...
- ADVANCED TPU-KNIT BOTTOM: Our base fabric transcends basic PVC by laminating...
Best for hot sleepers who want a 100% cotton top and need a deep pocket that fits mattresses up to 22 inches thick.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.