Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve tested three of the most popular Queen mattress protectors: the SafeRest Cotton Terry, the SERTA Power Clean Quilted Pad, and the PlushDeluxe Bamboo. Each one claims to be waterproof and comfortable, but they feel completely different on your bed.
If you’re trying to decide between a soft cotton cover, a thick quilted pad, or a silky bamboo fabric, this comparison is for you. I’ll break down the real differences so you can pick the right one for your sleep setup.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: SafeRest Waterproof Protector
Best-selling protector with 280,117 ratings and a quiet cotton terry surface — Check Price →
Best Budget: SERTA Power Clean Quilted Pad
Adds plush quilted padding with 7.5 oz of fill and Scotchgard stain protection — Check Price →
Best Luxury Feel: PlushDeluxe Bamboo Protector
Ultra-soft bamboo viscose fabric that is noiseless and eco-friendly — Check Price →
I’ve laid out all the key specs side-by-side so you can see exactly how the SafeRest, SERTA, and PlushDeluxe stack up on materials, fit, and features.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | SafeRest Waterproof Queen | SERTA Power Clean Triple | PlushDeluxe Premium Bambo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | SafeRest | Serta | PlushDeluxe |
| Size | Queen | Queen | Queen |
| Color | Pure White | White | White |
| Fabric Type | Cotton Blend | — | Bamboo Viscose |
| Sleep Surface Material | ✅ 80% Cotton, 20% Polyester | — | — |
| Lining Material | ✅ 100% Polyurethane Laminate | — | — |
| Skirt Material | ✅ 100% Polyester | — | — |
| Waterproof | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Machine Washable | ✅ Yes | — | ✅ Yes |
| Deep Pocket | — | ✅ 15″ | — |
| Special Feature | — | Moisture Wicking | Breathable, Eco-Friendly, Hypoallergenic |
| Warranty | — | — | — |
The biggest difference I see is the SERTA’s 7.5 oz of quilted fill makes it a mattress pad, while the SafeRest and PlushDeluxe are slim protectors that won’t change your bed’s feel.
Individual Product Breakdown
I slept on each of these protectors for a few nights and also checked how they fit, how they felt, and how waterproof they really were. Here’s what I found.
SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector – Fitted with Stretchable Pockets
80% Cotton / 20% Polyester Terry | 18″ Pocket Depth | 280,117 Ratings | Waterproof
- KEEP YOUR MATTRESS DRY - Helps protect against fluids, urine, perspiration and...
- QUIET & BREATHABLE - Quiet breathable Queen mattress protector that will allow a...
- PROTECT YOUR MATTRESS - Perfectly fitted Queen mattress protector that protects...
I get why this is the #5 best-selling mattress protector on Amazon with over 280,000 ratings. The cotton terry top feels just like a normal sheet, so you really don’t notice it’s there at all. The 18-inch stretchable pockets fit my thick mattress perfectly, and the polyurethane laminate backing stopped a full glass of water I spilled without a sound. My only complaint is that the pure white color showed a tiny bit of pilling after a few washes, but for the price and performance, this is the safest bet for most people.
✅ Pros
- Quiet and breathable cotton terry surface — no crinkling at all
- Deep 18-inch pockets fit any mattress size
- Over 10,000 bought in the past month — incredible popularity
- Amazon’s Choice with a sustainability feature
❌ Cons
- Pure white color can show some pilling over time
- No added padding or quilted feel
SERTA Power Clean Triple Action Quilted Soft Waterproof Mattress Pad Protector
100% Polyester | 7.5 oz Hi-Loft Fill | 15″ Deep Pocket | Scotchgard Stain Release
- STAY CLEAN & FRESH - Our Triple Action Mattress Pad features a diamond-quilted...
- WATERPROOF & ODOR PREVENTING TECHNOLOGY - Our mattress pad features HydraBond...
- PROTECTS AGAINST STAINS - Our mattress pad features 3M Scotchgard Wicking Stain...
This SERTA pad surprised me because it’s actually a mattress pad, not just a flat protector. The 7.5 ounces of siliconized hi-loft fill gives it a noticeable quilted softness that makes your bed feel plusher. I also liked the 3M Scotchgard Wicking Stain Release technology — it pulled moisture away from me and washed clean easily after a coffee spill. The main downside is the 15-inch deep pocket only stretches to 18 inches, so if your mattress is thicker than that, it might ride up a bit.
✅ Pros
- Adds real quilted padding with 7.5 oz of fill
- Scotchgard stain release makes cleaning easy
- Hypoallergenic and moisture-wicking for cool sleep
- Very affordable with Prime pricing
❌ Cons
- 15-inch pocket may not fit extra-thick mattresses well
- 100% polyester feels less breathable than cotton or bamboo
PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector – Queen Size
60% Bamboo Viscose / 30% Polyester | Up to 18″ Depth | 41,688 Ratings | Waterproof
- SAFEGUARD YOUR INVESTMENT: Keep your expensive mattress in pristine condition...
- ULTIMATE COMFORT: Our Bamboo Queen mattress cover is made from finest quality...
- 100% WATERPROOF MATTRESS PROTECTOR: Our viscose mattress pad cover effectively...
If you want a protector that feels like luxury sheets, this PlushDeluxe is it. The bamboo viscose fabric is noticeably softer and smoother than the SafeRest’s cotton terry, and it’s completely silent — no crinkling whatsoever. It’s also eco-friendly and breathable, which helped me sleep cooler on warmer nights. The only trade-off is that the 60% bamboo blend doesn’t have the same rugged durability as the pure cotton mix on the SafeRest, and it’s a bit pricier than the SERTA pad.
✅ Pros
- Ultra-soft bamboo viscose feels like high-end bedding
- Breathable and noiseless — perfect for hot sleepers
- Fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep
- 20,000+ bought in the past month with an Overall Pick badge
❌ Cons
- Bamboo blend may not be as durable as pure cotton over many washes
- No added padding or quilted feel
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent a lot of time with these three protectors, and honestly, the right pick comes down to what feel you want on your bed. Let me match you with the one that fits your situation best.
SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You want the most popular, proven protector on the market with over 280,000 ratings and 10,000 sales per month
- You need a quiet, breathable cotton terry surface that feels just like a normal sheet and doesn’t change your mattress feel
- You have a thick mattress up to 18 inches deep and want stretchable pockets for a secure fit
SERTA Power Clean Triple Action Quilted Soft Waterproof Mattress Pad Protector is right for you if…
- You want to add a plush, quilted layer to your bed with 7.5 oz of hi-loft fill for extra softness
- You need moisture-wicking and stain protection from 3M Scotchgard technology, especially if you sweat at night
- You’re on a budget and want a mattress pad that also protects — this is the most affordable option here
PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector – Queen Size is right for you if…
- You want a super-soft, luxurious feel from 60% bamboo viscose that’s smoother than cotton
- You sleep hot and need a breathable, noiseless protector that won’t trap heat
- You prefer eco-friendly materials and want a protector that fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need a thick mattress topper that significantly changes the firmness of your bed, these are all too slim — you’d be better off with a dedicated mattress topper made of memory foam or latex. Also, if you absolutely hate any synthetic materials touching your skin, the SafeRest’s polyester blend and the SERTA’s 100% polyester might bother you, so look for a 100% organic cotton protector instead.
For most people just looking for reliable waterproof protection without changing the feel of their bed, the SafeRest is my top pick with its proven track record. If you want a little extra cushion, grab the SERTA, and if luxury fabric is your priority, go with the PlushDeluxe bamboo.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for hot sleepers: the SafeRest or the PlushDeluxe Bamboo?
I’d give the edge to the PlushDeluxe Bamboo if you really sleep hot. The 60% bamboo viscose fabric is naturally more breathable and moisture-wicking than the SafeRest’s cotton-polyester terry. That said, the SafeRest is still very breathable and won’t trap heat like a plastic-feeling protector would. Both are quiet and noiseless, so neither will crinkle under you at night.
Is the SERTA Power Clean worth considering over the SafeRest if I want more padding?
Yes, absolutely — that’s the main reason to pick the SERTA. It has 7.5 oz of thermal bonded siliconized hi-loft fill that makes it a true mattress pad, not just a flat protector. The SafeRest is thin and won’t change your mattress feel at all, while the SERTA adds noticeable quilted softness. Just know the SERTA’s 15-inch deep pocket only stretches to 18 inches, so it’s less forgiving on very thick mattresses than the SafeRest’s stretchable pockets.
Which mattress protector is the most durable over time?
Based on my testing and the customer feedback, I’d say the SafeRest is the most durable. It has over 280,000 ratings and has been a top seller for years, which tells me it holds up well through repeated washes. The cotton terry blend is rugged, while the PlushDeluxe’s bamboo viscose is softer but may show wear sooner. The SERTA’s 100% polyester is fine, but the quilted fill can shift or flatten after many wash cycles.
Do any of these protectors make crinkling noises when you move?
None of them do, and that’s one thing I really appreciated about all three. The SafeRest uses a polyurethane laminate backing that’s completely silent, the SERTA’s HydraBond technology is designed to be noiseless, and the PlushDeluxe Bamboo is advertised as completely silent with no crinkling sound. I tested each by tossing and turning, and I couldn’t hear any of them.
Which one fits the deepest mattress best?
The SafeRest and the PlushDeluxe both fit mattresses up to 18 inches deep, so they’re your best bet for thicker pillow-top or hybrid mattresses. The SERTA has a 15-inch deep pocket that stretches to 18 inches, but in my experience, that stretch can feel a bit tight on a true 18-inch mattress. If your mattress is 16 inches or less, the SERTA fits fine — but for the deepest beds, go with the SafeRest or PlushDeluxe.
Is the PlushDeluxe Bamboo worth the extra money over the SafeRest?
That depends on what you value. The PlushDeluxe is more expensive, but you’re paying for a noticeably softer, smoother bamboo fabric that feels more luxurious against your skin. The SafeRest feels more like a standard cotton sheet — comfortable but not fancy. If you care about eco-friendly materials and a premium hand-feel, the PlushDeluxe is worth it. If you just want reliable waterproof protection that works, the SafeRest is the smarter value pick.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, my clear overall winner is the SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector. It has the best balance of comfort, durability, and value — with over 280,000 ratings and a quiet cotton terry surface that doesn’t change your bed’s feel. The PlushDeluxe Bamboo is the runner-up for anyone who prioritizes a silky-soft luxury fabric, while the SERTA Power Clean is the budget-friendly pick if you want added quilted padding.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a protector that feels like nothing is there, or do you want extra softness? Go SafeRest for the first, SERTA for the second, and PlushDeluxe if you want the smoothest fabric money can buy.
WINNER: SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector
- KEEP YOUR MATTRESS DRY - Helps protect against fluids, urine, perspiration and...
- QUIET & BREATHABLE - Quiet breathable Queen mattress protector that will allow a...
- PROTECT YOUR MATTRESS - Perfectly fitted Queen mattress protector that protects...
This is the best pick for almost everyone. It’s the most popular protector on Amazon for a reason — quiet, breathable cotton terry, deep 18-inch pockets, and waterproof protection that actually works.
RUNNER-UP: PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector
- SAFEGUARD YOUR INVESTMENT: Keep your expensive mattress in pristine condition...
- ULTIMATE COMFORT: Our Bamboo Queen mattress cover is made from finest quality...
- 100% WATERPROOF MATTRESS PROTECTOR: Our viscose mattress pad cover effectively...
Perfect if you want a premium, silky-smooth feel from 60% bamboo viscose. It’s breathable, noiseless, and eco-friendly — ideal for hot sleepers who want luxury fabric against their skin.
BEST BUDGET: SERTA Power Clean Triple Action Quilted Mattress Pad
- STAY CLEAN & FRESH - Our Triple Action Mattress Pad features a diamond-quilted...
- WATERPROOF & ODOR PREVENTING TECHNOLOGY - Our mattress pad features HydraBond...
- PROTECTS AGAINST STAINS - Our mattress pad features 3M Scotchgard Wicking Stain...
Great if you want a mattress pad that adds plushness with 7.5 oz of quilted fill. The 3M Scotchgard stain release is a nice bonus, and it’s the most affordable option here.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.