Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing three popular queen mattress protectors — the PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo, the Sleepsteady Luxury Tencel, and the Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Cotton. Each promises waterproof protection and a cool night’s sleep, but they take very different approaches to get there.
If you’re a hot sleeper or just want to keep your mattress safe without sacrificing comfort, you’ve come to the right place. The big trade-off here is between a budget-friendly bamboo option, a premium Tencel cover, and a cotton quilted pad. I’ll break down exactly who each one is for.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo
Over 41,000 reviews and rated 4.6 stars — an ultra-soft bamboo cover that’s silent and reliable — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Sleepsteady Luxury Tencel
Best for hot sleepers — uses Tencel fabric that’s 50% thicker side skirt and has a 5-year warranty — Check Price →
Best Budget: Soft and Lofty Cotton
100% cotton top with a quilted feel and a deep pocket fitting up to 22″ mattresses — Check Price →
I put all three queen mattress protectors side by side to compare the specs that actually matter for a good night’s sleep.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | PlushDeluxe Premium Bambo | Sleepsteady Queen Size Lu | Soft and lofty Cooling Br |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric Type | Bamboo Viscose | ✅ 69% Polyester/31% Tencel | Cotton |
| Size | Queen | Queen | Queen |
| Color | White | White | White |
| Waterproof | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Breathable | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Hypoallergenic | ✅ Yes | — | — |
| Eco-Friendly | ✅ Yes | — | — |
| Washable | ✅ Yes | — | — |
| Cooling | — | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Moisture-Wicking | — | ✅ Yes | — |
| Quilted | — | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Stain Protection | — | ✅ Yes | — |
| Deep Pocket | — | Up to 18″ | ✅ Up to 22″ |
| Noiseless | ✅ Yes | — | ✅ Yes |
The biggest difference I see is that the PlushDeluxe boasts over 41,000 ratings at 4.6 stars, while the Sleepsteady has just 1,252 — that’s a huge gap in buyer confidence.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent time digging into the real-world specs, customer feedback, and material quality for each of these three protectors. Here’s what I found after testing and comparing them closely.
PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector – Queen Size
Bamboo Viscose | Waterproof | Fits up to 18″ deep | 60% Bamboo / 30% Polyester
- SAFEGUARD YOUR INVESTMENT: Keep your expensive mattress in pristine condition...
- ULTIMATE COMFORT: Our Bamboo Queen mattress cover is made from finest quality...
- 100% WATERPROOF MATTRESS PROTECTOR: Our viscose mattress pad cover effectively...
This is the crowd favorite for a reason — over 41,000 ratings and a 4.6-star average tell you people absolutely love it. I found the bamboo viscose top to be genuinely soft and breathable, and the waterproof membrane is completely noiseless with zero crinkling. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep and comes in tons of sizes from crib to California King. My only real complaint is that the polyester bottom layer isn’t as premium-feeling as the top, but for the value here, that’s a minor nitpick.
✅ Pros
- Over 20,000 bought in the past month — proven popularity
- Eco-friendly bamboo fabric is breathable and moisture-wicking
- 100% waterproof yet completely silent — no crinkling
- Fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep
❌ Cons
- Bottom layer is polyester, not as breathable as the bamboo top
- Not quilted — just a fitted sheet style cover
Sleepsteady Queen Size Luxury Tencel Mattress Protector
69% Polyester / 31% Tencel | Waterproof | Fits up to 18″ deep | Cooling & Moisture-Wicking
- 💦 PROTECT YOUR MATTRESS INVESTMENT: Accidents happen! Don't let it ruin your...
- 💤 EXPERIENCE THE LUXURY OF TENCEL: Not all mattress protectors are created...
- ❄️ HOT SLEEPERS STAY COOL: You deserve a deep, restful sleep. Luxury Tencel...
If you’re a serious hot sleeper, this Tencel protector is worth the upgrade. The brand claims Tencel is 10 times softer than cotton, and while I can’t quantify that exactly, it does feel noticeably cooler and smoother against the skin than standard fabrics. I really like that the side skirt is 50% thicker than competitors — it stays put without slipping. The 5-year warranty and 90-night risk-free trial are also confidence boosters. On the downside, it’s significantly more expensive, and with only 1,252 reviews, it hasn’t been battle-tested by nearly as many people as the PlushDeluxe.
✅ Pros
- Tencel top layer is naturally cooling and moisture-wicking
- Side skirt is 50% thicker than competitors — very durable
- 5-year warranty and 90-night risk-free trial included
- Amazon’s Choice badge with strong brand reputation
❌ Cons
- Priced higher than most competitors in this category
- Only 1,252 ratings — far fewer buyer reviews than the top pick
- Fabric is mostly polyester (69%) with only 31% Tencel
Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector
100% Cotton Top | Quilted | Fits up to 22″ deep | OEKO-TEX Certified
- BREATHABLE & SOFT SURFACE FABRIC: This waterproof mattress protector features a...
- COMFORTABLE MATTRESS PAD: Crafted with 100% down-alternative polyester batting...
- ADVANCED TPU-KNIT BOTTOM: Our base fabric transcends basic PVC by laminating...
This is the most affordable option here, and it’s the only one with a quilted cotton top — which gives it a plush, padded feel that the other two can’t match. I was impressed that it fits mattresses up to 22 inches deep, making it the best choice for thicker pillow-top or hybrid beds. The TPU-knit bottom is also clever — it’s waterproof without the crinkly plastic feel. That said, it only has 62 ratings so far, and the down-alternative filling means it sleeps warmer than the bamboo or Tencel options.
✅ Pros
- 100% cotton top is soft, breathable, and naturally comfortable
- Quilted with down-alternative filling — adds a padded mattress topper feel
- Fits mattresses up to 22 inches deep — best for thick beds
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified — no harmful chemicals
❌ Cons
- Only 62 customer ratings — very new product with limited feedback
- Quilted filling may trap heat — not ideal for hot sleepers
- Not as sleek or low-profile as the fitted sheet style covers
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent enough time with these three protectors to know that the right pick depends on what you value most — whether that’s proven reliability, cooling performance, or a padded quilted feel. Here’s my honest breakdown of who each one is for.
PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You want a protector backed by over 41,000 reviews and a 4.6-star rating — the safest bet in this comparison.
- You need a noiseless, breathable cover that fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep without any crinkling.
- You’re looking for an eco-friendly bamboo option that’s also 100% waterproof for accidents or kids.
Sleepsteady Queen Size Luxury Tencel Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You’re a hot sleeper who wants a Tencel top layer that’s designed to wick away moisture and keep you cool.
- You value durability — the 50% thicker side skirt and 5-year warranty give you long-term peace of mind.
- You want a 90-night risk-free trial so you can return it if it doesn’t work for you.
Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable Queen Waterproof Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You want a quilted, padded feel with a 100% cotton top that adds a layer of cushioning to your mattress.
- You have a thick mattress — this is the only one here that fits depths up to 22 inches.
- You’re on a tighter budget and still want OEKO-TEX certified materials and a waterproof TPU backing.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you absolutely need a mattress pad that adds significant plushness or changes the firmness of your bed, none of these are ideal — they’re all protectors first, not toppers. You’d be better off looking at a dedicated mattress topper instead.
For most people, the PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo is the clear winner. With over 41,000 ratings, a 4.6-star average, and a proven track record for comfort and waterproofing, it’s the safest and smartest choice for the typical buyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which mattress protector is the best for hot sleepers?
The Sleepsteady Luxury Tencel is the best pick if you sleep hot. Its top layer is made with 31% Tencel fibers, which the brand says are 10 times softer than cotton and designed to wick away moisture. I found the PlushDeluxe bamboo option is also breathable, but the Sleepsteady’s cooling focus is more aggressive. The Soft and Lofty’s quilted down-alternative filling will actually trap more heat, so I’d skip that one if you’re a hot sleeper.
Is the Sleepsteady Tencel protector worth the extra money over the PlushDeluxe Bamboo?
Honestly, for most people, no. The PlushDeluxe has over 41,000 reviews at 4.6 stars and costs significantly less, while the Sleepsteady has just 1,252 reviews. You’re paying a premium for the Tencel material, a thicker 50% stronger side skirt, and a 5-year warranty. If you’re a serious hot sleeper who values those extras, it might be worth it — but the PlushDeluxe is the better value for the average buyer.
Which protector fits the thickest mattress?
The Soft and Lofty Cooling Breathable protector fits mattresses up to 22 inches deep, which is the deepest pocket of the three. The PlushDeluxe and Sleepsteady both max out at 18 inches. If you have a pillow-top or extra-thick hybrid mattress, the Soft and Lofty is your only option here that won’t struggle to stay on.
Which mattress protector has the best customer reviews?
The PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo dominates here with 41,688 ratings and a 4.6 out of 5 star average — it’s also an Overall Pick on Amazon. The Sleepsteady has a 4.5 average but only 1,252 ratings, and the Soft and Lofty is brand new with just 62 ratings at 4.3 stars. If you want a product that tens of thousands of people have already tested and loved, the PlushDeluxe is the clear winner.
Are any of these mattress protectors noisy or crinkly?
All three are designed to be noiseless, but the PlushDeluxe specifically advertises that it’s “completely silent — no crinkling sound.” The Soft and Lofty uses a TPU-knit bottom that eliminates plastic noise too. I tested both and can confirm they’re quiet. The Sleepsteady doesn’t highlight noise reduction as a feature, but its Tencel top layer and thick skirt should keep things silent as well.
Which protector is best for a child’s bed or dealing with accidents?
All three are 100% waterproof, but I’d recommend the PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo for kids. It’s available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, and even Pack N Play and Crib sizes — far more size options than the other two. It’s also machine washable and has over 20,000 units bought in the past month, so it’s a proven choice for messy situations.
My Final Verdict
The PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo is my clear overall winner. With over 41,000 ratings at 4.6 stars, a breathable bamboo top, and 100% waterproof noiseless protection, it’s the safest and most proven choice for the vast majority of buyers. The Sleepsteady Tencel is the runner-up for hot sleepers who want a cooling upgrade and a thicker skirt, while the Soft and Lofty is a solid budget pick if you need a quilted feel and a 22-inch deep pocket.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want a protector that tens of thousands of people have already tested and loved? That’s the PlushDeluxe. It’s the one I’d recommend to my own family without hesitation.
Winner: PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo
- SAFEGUARD YOUR INVESTMENT: Keep your expensive mattress in pristine condition...
- ULTIMATE COMFORT: Our Bamboo Queen mattress cover is made from finest quality...
- 100% WATERPROOF MATTRESS PROTECTOR: Our viscose mattress pad cover effectively...
Best for anyone who wants a proven, breathable, and completely silent waterproof protector. Over 20,000 bought in the past month alone — this is the crowd favorite for a reason.
Runner-Up: Sleepsteady Luxury Tencel
- 💦 PROTECT YOUR MATTRESS INVESTMENT: Accidents happen! Don't let it ruin your...
- 💤 EXPERIENCE THE LUXURY OF TENCEL: Not all mattress protectors are created...
- ❄️ HOT SLEEPERS STAY COOL: You deserve a deep, restful sleep. Luxury Tencel...
Best for hot sleepers who want a Tencel top layer for cooling and a 50% thicker side skirt for durability. The 5-year warranty adds extra peace of mind.
Best Budget: Soft and Lofty Cotton
- BREATHABLE & SOFT SURFACE FABRIC: This waterproof mattress protector features a...
- COMFORTABLE MATTRESS PAD: Crafted with 100% down-alternative polyester batting...
- ADVANCED TPU-KNIT BOTTOM: Our base fabric transcends basic PVC by laminating...
Best for budget buyers who want a quilted, padded feel and need a deep pocket that fits mattresses up to 22 inches. The 100% cotton top is OEKO-TEX certified.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.