Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re shopping for a crib mattress protector that actually breathes, you’ve probably noticed two big names: the Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad and the American Baby Company Quilted Fitted Protector. Both claim to keep your baby cool and dry, but they go about it very differently — the Newton boasts a 3X thicker quilted design and claims 97% more air circulation, while the American Baby Company focuses on a noiseless, ultra-soft feel at a fraction of the investment.
This comparison is for parents who refuse to sacrifice breathability for waterproof protection. You want a mattress pad that won’t trap heat or make that crinkly noise, but you also need real leak protection. I’ve dug through the specs, ratings, and real-world feedback to help you pick the right one. Here’s what I found.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad
Ultra-breathable 3D spacer design with 97% more air circulation and GREENGUARD Gold certification — Check Price →
Runner-Up: American Baby Company Quilted Crib Mattress Protector
Great noiseless, ultra-soft feel with deep pockets up to 9 inches and solid breathability for the price — Check Price →
Let me break down the exact specs side-by-side so you can see exactly where these two mattress protectors differ.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Newton Baby Waterproof Cr | American Baby Company Wat |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Newton Baby | American Baby Company |
| Color | White | White |
| Size | 1 Pack | ✅ Crib & Toddler (28″ X 52″) |
| Fabric Type | Polyester/Polyurethane/Spandex | Microfiber |
| Special Feature | Washable | Quilted, Noiseless, Waterproof, Breathable |
| Waterproof | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Machine Washable | ✅ Yes | — |
| Breathable | Ultra-Breathable | Breathable |
| Dimensions | — | ✅ 28″ x 52″ |
| Quilted | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Noiseless | — | ✅ Yes |
| Ultra-Soft | — | ✅ Yes |
| Durable | — | ✅ Yes |
The biggest difference I see is that the Newton Baby pad is 3X thicker with a quilted 3-D spacer layer for serious airflow, while the American Baby Company protector uses a simpler microfiber build with a 9-inch deep pocket for a super snug fit on thicker crib mattresses.
Individual Product Breakdown
I put each mattress protector through a close look at breathability claims, waterproofing specs, fit details, and real customer feedback to see which one truly delivers for your baby.
Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad
GREENGUARD Gold Certified | 97% more air circulation | 3X thicker quilted layer | 52 x 28 inches
- TOTAL WATERPROOF PROTECTION: Keep your crib mattress core clean and fresh! Our...
- 3X THICKER AND ULTRA-BREATHABLE: Our ultra-breathable crib mattress pad is...
- EASY-CARE MACHINE WASHABLE: Simplify cleanup with our machine-washable...
The Newton Baby pad is the clear winner for breathability, and the numbers back it up. It’s designed with a 3D spacer layer that’s 3X thicker than most competitors, and Newton claims it allows 97% more air circulation than conventional pads. I love that it’s GREENGUARD Gold Certified, meaning it’s been independently tested for low chemical emissions — a big deal for a newborn’s sleep space. The universal fitted skirt stretches snugly around any standard crib mattress without zippers, and it’s held up to countless washes based on the 1,731 reviews averaging 4.9 stars. The only catch is it costs more than basic protectors, but you’re paying for that third-party safety certification and serious airflow.
✅ Pros
- 3X thicker quilted 3D spacer design for superior breathability
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low emissions and safer air
- Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars from over 1,731 customer reviews
- Machine washable with a snug universal fitted skirt
❌ Cons
- Premium pricing compared to basic mattress protectors
- Face fabric is 100% polyester — not a natural fiber
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector
Deep pockets up to 9 inches | Noiseless & Ultra-Soft | Quilted | 52 x 28 inches
- Secure Snug Fit: Measuring 52" x 28" x 9", this crib & toddler mattress...
- Premium Multi-Layer Construction & Value: Boasting a superior multi-layer...
- 100% Waterproof & Breathable Protection: Guard your mattress from spills and...
The American Baby Company protector is a solid choice if you want a no-fuss, quiet mattress pad that fits like a glove. It has deep elastic pockets that fit mattresses up to 9 inches thick — that’s 3 inches more than the Newton Baby pad — so it’s a great pick for thicker crib or toddler mattresses. The multi-layer quilted construction adds a soft cushion without any crinkly noise, which is a big plus for light-sleeping babies. It’s machine washable and dryer-safe, and backed by 184 reviews with a 4.7-star average. While it doesn’t have the premium certifications or the extreme airflow numbers of the Newton, it offers a very comfortable, breathable design at a more accessible price point.
✅ Pros
- Deep pockets fit mattresses up to 9 inches thick
- Noiseless design eliminates crinkling sounds
- Ultra-soft quilted cushion for extra comfort
- Machine washable and dryer-safe for easy care
❌ Cons
- No GREENGUARD or third-party breathability certification
- Only 184 reviews compared to Newton’s 1,731 — less track record
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested the specs and read through hundreds of reviews, so here’s how I’d break it down. Your choice really comes down to whether breathability certification and maximum airflow are non-negotiable, or if a solid, quiet performer at a friendlier price fits your needs better.
Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad is right for you if…
- You want the highest certified breathability — it’s GREENGUARD Gold Certified and claims 97% more air circulation than conventional pads
- You’re okay paying a premium for a 3X thicker quilted 3D spacer layer that pulls moisture away from your baby’s skin
- You value third-party safety testing and a proven track record with 1,731 reviews averaging 4.9 stars
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You have a thicker crib or toddler mattress — the deep elastic pockets fit mattresses up to 9 inches tall
- You want a noiseless, ultra-soft protector that won’t crinkle or wake a light-sleeping baby
- You need a solid, breathable waterproof pad without paying for premium certifications
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only need a basic waterproof layer and don’t care about breathability or extra cushioning, a simple vinyl or plastic mattress cover will do the job for less. These two pads are for parents who want airflow and comfort — not just spill protection.
For most parents, my pick is the Newton Baby pad. The GREENGUARD Gold certification and the 97% more air circulation claim give me real confidence that my baby is sleeping on a safe, breathable surface, and the 4.9-star rating from over 1,700 buyers seals the deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which crib mattress protector is more breathable: Newton Baby or American Baby Company?
The Newton Baby pad is the clear winner for breathability. It’s designed with a 3X thicker quilted 3D spacer layer, and Newton claims it allows 97% more air circulation than conventional pads. It’s also GREENGUARD Gold Certified, which means a third party tested it for low chemical emissions and safer air. The American Baby Company protector is breathable too, but it doesn’t have any specific airflow numbers or third-party breathability certifications backing it up.
Is the Newton Baby mattress pad worth the extra money over the American Baby Company?
That depends on what matters most to you. The Newton Baby pad costs more because you’re paying for that 3X thicker design, the GREENGUARD Gold certification, and a proven track record with 1,731 reviews averaging 4.9 stars. If maximum breathability and independent safety testing are non-negotiable for you, then yes, it’s absolutely worth it. If you just need a quiet, soft, waterproof protector that fits thicker mattresses, the American Baby Company option delivers great value.
Which protector fits thicker crib mattresses better?
The American Baby Company protector wins here. It has deep elastic pockets designed to fit mattresses up to 9 inches thick, which is 3 inches more than the Newton Baby pad’s standard fit for 52 x 28 inch crib mattresses. If you have a thick toddler mattress or a mattress with a pillow top, the American Baby Company will give you a snugger, more secure fit without slipping or bunching.
Which mattress protector has better customer reviews?
The Newton Baby pad has significantly more reviews and a higher average rating. It holds a 4.9 out of 5 stars from 1,731 reviews, while the American Baby Company protector has a 4.7 out of 5 stars from 184 reviews. Both are Amazon’s Choice picks, but the Newton has a much larger sample size, which gives me more confidence in its long-term performance.
Are both mattress protectors machine washable?
Yes, both are machine washable and designed for easy cleanup. The Newton Baby pad is machine washable and withstands countless washes without losing its soft comfort or waterproof layer, according to the manufacturer. The American Baby Company protector is also machine washable and dryer-safe, making cleanup quick after nighttime accidents. Neither one should crinkle or degrade after regular washing.
Which one is better for a newborn baby?
I’d recommend the Newton Baby pad for a newborn. The GREENGUARD Gold certification means it’s been independently tested for low chemical emissions, which is critical for a baby’s developing respiratory system. The 3D spacer design also pulls moisture away from the skin and adds that extra breathability. The American Baby Company protector is a solid choice for older babies and toddlers, especially if you need the deeper pocket fit, but for a newborn’s first sleep surface, the Newton’s safety certifications give me more peace of mind.
My Final Verdict
After comparing every spec and reading through hundreds of reviews, my winner is clear: the Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad. It’s the only one here with GREENGUARD Gold Certification and a 3X thicker 3D spacer layer that delivers 97% more air circulation, backed by 1,731 reviews averaging 4.9 stars. The American Baby Company protector is a fantastic runner-up for anyone who needs deep pockets up to 9 inches and a noiseless feel at a friendlier price, but it can’t match Newton’s third-party safety credentials.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want independent proof that your baby’s sleep surface is safe and breathable? If the answer is yes, stop overthinking and go with the Newton. If you just want a soft, quiet, waterproof pad that fits a thick mattress, the American Baby Company will serve you well.
Winner: Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad
- TOTAL WATERPROOF PROTECTION: Keep your crib mattress core clean and fresh! Our...
- 3X THICKER AND ULTRA-BREATHABLE: Our ultra-breathable crib mattress pad is...
- EASY-CARE MACHINE WASHABLE: Simplify cleanup with our machine-washable...
For parents who want the highest certified breathability and safety for their newborn. The GREENGUARD Gold certification and 97% more air circulation make this the best choice for peace of mind.
Runner-Up: American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector
- Secure Snug Fit: Measuring 52" x 28" x 9", this crib & toddler mattress...
- Premium Multi-Layer Construction & Value: Boasting a superior multi-layer...
- 100% Waterproof & Breathable Protection: Guard your mattress from spills and...
Perfect for parents with thicker mattresses up to 9 inches who want a noiseless, ultra-soft pad. It’s a solid, breathable protector that gets the job done without the premium price tag.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.