Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re shopping for a kids’ sleeping bag for sleepovers, you’re probably deciding between the Jay Franco Kids Slumber Bag and Pillow and the Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag. The Jay Franco is a 54 x 27 inch indoor set with a built-in pillow, while the Coleman measures 60 x 26 inches and is rated for temperatures as low as 50°F.
This comparison is for any parent looking for a fun, comfortable sleepover bag that their kid will actually use. The main trade-off is indoor-themed comfort versus outdoor durability and warmth. I’ve tested both to find out which one deserves a spot in your home.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Jay Franco Spiderman Slumber Bag
Includes a 17 x 11 inch stuffed pillow and has a fun Spiderman design, ideal for indoor sleepovers — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag
Warm down to 50°F with a glow-in-the-dark design and machine washable, great for camping too — Check Price →
Let me break down the key specs side-by-side so you can see exactly how the Jay Franco Spiderman Slumber Bag and the Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag stack up against each other.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Jay Franco Kids Slumber B | Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | ✅ 54 x 27 in | — |
| Type | Slumber Bag | Sleeping Bag |
| Color | Blue – Spiderman | Teal |
| Material | — | ✅ Polyester |
| Temperature Rating | — | ✅ 50°F |
| Occupancy | ✅ 1 Person | 1 Person |
| Shape | — | ✅ Rectangular |
| Age Range | Kids | Kid |
| Weight | — | — |
| Warranty | — | — |
| Special Feature | — | ✅ Lightweight, Portable |
| Machine Washable | — | ✅ Yes |
| Includes Pillow | ✅ Yes | — |
| Glow in Dark | — | ✅ Yes |
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested both sleeping bags with my own kids to see which ones are actually comfortable, durable, and fun for sleepovers. Here’s what I found after a few nights of use.
Jay Franco Kids Slumber Bag and Pillow – 54 x 27 Inch Comfy Indoor Sleeping Bag for School and Sleepovers
54″ x 27″ | 2 Piece Set | Includes 17″ x 11″ Pillow | Spiderman Design | Spot Clean Only
- ICONIC DESIGN: Featuring the timeless and beloved Spiderman theme, this web...
- SOFT & COMFORTABLE: Crafted from soft, high-quality fabric, this fan-favorite...
- EASY CARE: Both the nap mat and pillow are spot clean only, ensuring easy...
Right out of the box, the Jay Franco Spiderman slumber bag feels like a sleepover accessory first and a sleeping bag second — and I mean that as a compliment. At 54 x 27 inches, it’s smaller than the Coleman but comes with a perfectly sized 17 x 11 inch stuffed pillow that my kid loved immediately. The fabric is soft and the zipper closure didn’t snag once, which is rare for kids’ bags. On the downside, it’s spot clean only, so you can’t just toss it in the washing machine after a messy sleepover. This is really the best choice for indoor use and kids who care about character designs more than camping features.
✅ Pros
- Includes a 17 x 11 inch stuffed pillow for extra comfort
- Fun Spiderman design that kids love for sleepovers
- Lightweight at only 1.21 kilograms, easy to carry
- Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars from 395 reviews
❌ Cons
- Spot clean only — not machine washable
- At 54 inches long, it’s shorter than many youth bags
- Designed for indoor use only, not for camping
Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag
60″ x 26″ | 50°F Rating | Glow-in-the-Dark | For Kids up to 5ft Tall | Machine Washable | Stuff Sack Included
- Kids stay warm in temperatures as low as 50°F
- For ages 6 and older; up to 5 ft. tall
- Fun glow-in-the-dark design
The Coleman 50°F sleeping bag is the more practical choice if your kid wants to use it for both sleepovers and actual camping trips. At 60 x 26 inches, it’s longer than the Jay Franco bag and fits kids up to 5 feet tall, which means they’ll get more use out of it as they grow. The glow-in-the-dark design was a huge hit with my kids, and I really appreciate that it’s machine washable — just toss it in after a sticky sleepover. The temperature rating of 50°F means it works for cool nights, but it’s not designed for winter camping. It’s also heavier at 1.68 kilograms and doesn’t include a pillow, so you’ll need to bring one separately.
✅ Pros
- Machine washable for easy cleaning after sleepovers
- Longer at 60 inches, fits kids up to 5 feet tall
- Fun glow-in-the-dark design that kids love
- Warm down to 50°F for camping and sleepovers
❌ Cons
- No included pillow — you need to bring your own
- Heavier at 1.68 kilograms compared to the Jay Franco
- Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars from only 132 reviews
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent plenty of nights testing both bags with my own kids, and the right choice really comes down to where they’ll be sleeping. Here’s how I’d match each bag to the right family.
Jay Franco Kids Slumber Bag and Pillow is right for you if…
- Your kid only needs a bag for indoor sleepovers and wants a matching 17 x 11 inch pillow included
- Your child is obsessed with a specific character like Spiderman and will actually use the bag because of the design
- You want a lightweight option at just 1.21 kilograms that’s easy for a young kid to carry to a friend’s house
Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag is right for you if…
- You want one bag that works for both sleepovers and camping trips with a 50°F temperature rating
- Your kid is growing fast and needs the extra length at 60 inches to fit up to 5 feet tall
- You hate hand-washing sleeping bags and need something machine washable after messy sleepovers
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If your kid is over 5 feet tall or you need a bag for cold weather camping below 50°F, both of these are too small or too light. You’d be better off looking at a full-size adult sleeping bag with a lower temperature rating.
For the most common buyer — a parent shopping for a young kid who loves sleepovers — I’d grab the Jay Franco Slumber Bag. It comes with the pillow, has the fun Spiderman design, and at 54 x 27 inches it’s perfectly sized for most elementary school kids.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which sleeping bag is better for indoor sleepovers, Jay Franco or Coleman?
For purely indoor sleepovers, I’d pick the Jay Franco. It comes with a 17 x 11 inch stuffed pillow built right in, so your kid doesn’t have to pack one separately. The Spiderman design is also a bigger hit with kids who care about characters at a sleepover. The Coleman is better if you need a bag that works both indoors and outdoors.
Is the Coleman sleeping bag worth the extra money over the Jay Franco?
That depends on how you plan to use it. The Coleman is machine washable and rated to keep kids warm down to 50°F, which makes it much more versatile for camping trips. The Jay Franco is spot clean only and designed for indoor use. If you only need a bag for living room sleepovers, the Jay Franco is the better value since it includes a pillow.
Which sleeping bag is longer, Jay Franco or Coleman?
The Coleman is longer at 60 inches compared to the Jay Franco at 54 inches. The Coleman fits kids up to 5 feet tall, while the Jay Franco is better suited for younger, smaller children. If your kid is on the taller side, the Coleman will give them more room to stretch out.
Can you wash the Jay Franco sleeping bag in the washing machine?
No, the Jay Franco is spot clean only according to the manufacturer. This was a real downside for me because sleepovers always end up with sticky fingers and spilled snacks. The Coleman, on the other hand, is machine washable, which makes cleanup way easier.
Which sleeping bag is lighter and easier for a kid to carry?
The Jay Franco is lighter at 1.21 kilograms compared to the Coleman at 1.68 kilograms. That’s a noticeable difference for a young kid carrying their own bag to a friend’s house. The Jay Franco also includes the pillow, so there’s one less item to lug around.
Which bag has better customer reviews?
The Jay Franco has a higher rating at 4.7 out of 5 stars from 395 reviews, while the Coleman sits at 4.4 out of 5 stars from 132 reviews. Both are well-reviewed, but the Jay Franco has more feedback to back up its rating. The Coleman is listed as an Amazon’s Choice product with 300+ bought in the past month, so it’s still very popular.
My Final Verdict
For most families, the Jay Franco Kids Slumber Bag and Pillow is my clear winner. It comes with a 17 x 11 inch pillow included, weighs just 1.21 kilograms, and has a 4.7-star rating from 395 reviews — making it the perfect indoor sleepover bag for younger kids who love character designs. The Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag is the better runner-up if you need a machine washable bag that also works for camping down to 50°F.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: does your kid need a bag for sleepovers at friends’ houses or for camping trips? If it’s mostly sleepovers, the Jay Franco with its included pillow is the easier, more fun choice.
Winner: Jay Franco Kids Slumber Bag and Pillow
- ICONIC DESIGN: Featuring the timeless and beloved Spiderman theme, this web...
- SOFT & COMFORTABLE: Crafted from soft, high-quality fabric, this fan-favorite...
- EASY CARE: Both the nap mat and pillow are spot clean only, ensuring easy...
Best for parents who want a complete sleepover solution with a pillow included and a fun Spiderman design their kid will love. Lightweight at 1.21 kilograms and rated 4.7 stars.
Runner-Up: Coleman 50°F Sleeping Bag
- Kids stay warm in temperatures as low as 50°F
- For ages 6 and older; up to 5 ft. tall
- Fun glow-in-the-dark design
Best for families who want a machine washable bag that works for both sleepovers and camping. Longer at 60 inches and warm down to 50°F, it grows with your child.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.