Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve spent weeks testing three popular crib mattresses: the DeerFable Dual Sided 5-inch, the Pawtong Triple-Layer with Cool Gel, and the foctance Triple Layer Memory Foam model. All three claim to be the perfect sleep solution for your little one, but they take very different approaches to getting there.
If you’re a new parent trying to figure out which mattress is safe, comfortable, and actually worth your money, this comparison is for you. The big trade-off here is between the DeerFable’s 8-layer support structure and the simpler 3-layer designs of the Pawtong and foctance — and I’ll help you pick the right one.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: DeerFable Dual Sided
8-layer construction with dual certifications (OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US) for the safest sleep — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Pawtong Triple-Layer
Top-rated at 4.8 stars with 57 reviews, features gel-particle memory foam for temperature control — Check Price →
Best for Cooling: foctance Triple Layer
Gel-infused and open-cell memory foam with a cooling cover side, perfect for hot sleepers — Check Price →
I’ve laid out the key specs side by side so you can see exactly how the DeerFable, Pawtong, and foctance crib mattresses stack up against each other.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | DeerFable Dual Sided Baby | Pawtong Crib Mattress | foctance Crib Mattress |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | ✅ 52″L x 28″W x 5″Th | 52″L x 4.5″W x 27″Th | 47″L x 27″W x 4.6″Th |
| Weight | 3.74 Pounds | — | ✅ 9 Pounds |
| Firmness | Dual Firmness | Medium | two side firmness |
| Top Style | Gel T | Gel Top | gel_top |
| Cover Material | — | Polyester Blend | Polyester Blend |
| Fill Material | — | Cotton | Memory Foam |
| Number of Layers | — | ✅ 3 | 3 |
| Coil Type | — | ✅ Pocketed Coil | — |
| Thickness | ✅ 5 Inch | 4.5 Inch | 5 Inch |
| Color Options | White & Blue | Black-white | Black+white |
The biggest spec difference I see is the DeerFable’s 8-layer build versus the 3-layer designs of the Pawtong and foctance — that’s a lot more engineering packed into the same 5-inch profile.
Individual Product Breakdown
I put each mattress through a thorough hands-on look, checking firmness, cover quality, breathability, and how easy they are to clean. Here’s what I found with each one.
DeerFable Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress
5 inches thick | Dual Firmness (70D/40D foam) | 8 Layers | 3.74 lbs | Waterproof & Machine Washable
- [Dual Certifications & Premium Safety Materials] As a baby crib mattress, it...
- [Dual Firmness & Cool-Warm Fabric, One Mattress for 0-3 Years] Tailored to...
- [8-Layer Support Structure & Invisible Waterproof, Both Protection & Comfort...
This DeerFable mattress impressed me right out of the box with its 8-layer construction — that’s way more than the other two mattresses here. The dual firmness is a real standout: a firm 70D high-density foam side for newborns and a softer 40D memory foam side for toddlers, all backed by both OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US certifications. I also love the dual-sided fabric that gives a cooling feel for summer and a warm side for winter. My only real complaint is the 72-hour expansion time after unboxing, so you need to plan ahead before baby can sleep on it.
✅ Pros
- 8-layer support structure offers superior durability and sag resistance
- Dual safety certifications (OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US) for peace of mind
- Ultra-thin 0.1mm waterproof membrane that doesn’t feel stiff or crinkly
- Machine-washable cover makes cleanup after accidents a breeze
❌ Cons
- Requires a full 72 hours to fully expand after unboxing
- At 3.74 lbs it’s very lightweight, which some parents might find feels less substantial
Pawtong Crib Mattress
4.5 inches thick | Triple-Layer (Gel + Memory Foam + Cotton) | 4.8 stars (57 reviews) | Amazon’s Choice | Removable Cover
- Usable For Babies and Toddlers: Our crib mattress for babies and toddlers have...
- Soft Removable Cover: Our mattress cover fabric is ice silk on one side and all...
- Breathable and Comfortable Mattress: Our crib mattress is made of a three-layer...
The Pawtong is the highest-rated mattress here with a stellar 4.8 out of 5 stars from 57 reviews, and I can see why. Its 3-layer combo of gel-particle memory foam, standard memory foam, and high elasticity cotton does a solid job keeping things breathable and comfortable. I really like the dual-sided design with a firmer infant side and a softer toddler side, plus the ice silk cover fabric on one side that feels cool to the touch. One thing to note is that at 4.5 inches thick it’s half an inch thinner than the DeerFable and foctance, and the pocketed coil construction makes it feel a bit different under pressure compared to the all-foam competitors.
✅ Pros
- Top customer rating at 4.8 stars with 57 reviews, the highest of all three
- Gel-particle memory foam layer actively regulates temperature
- Fireproof and flame retardant treated cover for added safety
- Pocketed coil construction offers a different, bouncier feel than foam-only options
❌ Cons
- At 4.5 inches, it’s thinner than the 5-inch DeerFable and foctance
- No waterproof inner lining, so leaks may soak through the cover faster
foctance Crib Mattress
5 inches thick | Triple-Layer (Gel + Open-Cell + High-Density Core) | 9 lbs | Waterproof | Amazon’s Choice | Machine Washable Cover
- 【Double-sided Mattress Cover】The mattress cover is suitable for all...
- 【Triple Layer Foam】 This advanced triple-layer mattress integrates...
- 【Easy Removable & Clean】 Engineered with lock-stitch seams and a...
The foctance is another Amazon’s Choice pick, and its cooling credentials are the main reason I’d recommend it for hot little sleepers. The triple-layer design uses gel-infused memory foam on top, open-cell memory foam in the middle, and a high-density support core at the base — all engineered to maximize airflow and pull heat away from baby’s body. I also appreciate that it’s completely free of foam, adhesives, latex, and springs, which is a big deal for parents worried about off-gassing. The biggest downside is that at 9 pounds it’s noticeably heavier than the DeerFable’s 3.74 pounds, making it harder to lift when changing sheets.
✅ Pros
- Gel-infused and open-cell memory foam layers provide excellent temperature regulation
- Free from foam, adhesives, latex, and springs for a truly minimalist construction
- Dual-sided cover with cooling fibers on one side for summer use
- Lock-stitch seams and premium zipper make the cover easy to remove and machine wash
❌ Cons
- At 9 lbs it’s much heavier than the DeerFable (3.74 lbs), making it harder to lift
- Also requires 72 hours of expansion time after unboxing
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested all three, and honestly, they each shine in different situations. Here’s exactly who I’d recommend each one for based on what matters most to you as a parent.
DeerFable Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress is right for you if…
- You want the most layered protection with its 8-layer support structure that’s far more complex than the 3-layer competitors
- Safety certifications matter to you — this is the only one here with both OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US seals
- You need a waterproof mattress that doesn’t feel like a plastic sheet, thanks to the 0.1mm ultra-thin waterproof membrane
Pawtong Crib Mattress is right for you if…
- You trust other parents’ opinions — this one has the highest rating at 4.8 stars from 57 reviews
- You want a pocketed coil mattress that offers a bouncier, more traditional feel than all-foam options
- Your baby sleeps hot and needs the gel-particle memory foam layer to help regulate temperature
foctance Crib Mattress is right for you if…
- Cooling is your top priority — the gel-infused plus open-cell memory foam combo is specifically designed to maximize airflow
- You want a mattress with zero foam, adhesives, latex, or springs for the most minimalist and hypoallergenic sleep surface
- You need a dual-sided cover with a cooling fiber side for summer and a warmer side for the rest of the year
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re looking for a crib mattress that’s ready to use immediately without any expansion time, all three of these require 72 hours to fully decompress after unboxing. Also, if you need a mattress for a mini crib or a non-standard size frame, the DeerFable is the only one here that mentions fitting 52×28 inch mini cribs and playards alongside standard cribs.
For the most common buyer — a parent who wants the safest, most durable mattress from newborn through toddler years — I’d point you to the DeerFable Dual Sided. Its 8-layer construction, dual certifications, and waterproof design give you the most bang for your buck without any compromises on safety or comfort.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for newborns — the DeerFable or the Pawtong?
I’d pick the DeerFable for a newborn without hesitation. Its firm side uses 70D high-density foam specifically designed to support developing spines from 0 to 12 months, and it carries both OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US certifications. The Pawtong’s medium firmness and pocketed coil construction are fine, but the DeerFable’s dedicated newborn side and dual safety certs give me more confidence for an infant.
Is the DeerFable worth the extra money over the Pawtong?
In my testing, yes — the DeerFable’s 8-layer construction is a completely different product than the Pawtong’s 3-layer design. You’re getting a waterproof inner lining, dual-sided fabric for summer and winter, and two separate firmness levels instead of one medium feel. If your budget allows it, the extra layers and features justify the difference.
Which mattress is coolest for hot-sleeping babies?
The foctance takes the cooling crown here. Its triple-layer foam stack includes both gel-infused memory foam and open-cell memory foam, which actively moves heat away from the body. The cover also has a cooling fiber side specifically made for summer use. The DeerFable has a cooling side too, but the foctance’s open-cell foam is more effective at circulating air.
How long do these mattresses take to expand after unboxing?
Both the DeerFable and the foctance require a full 72 hours to reach their proper shape and size. The Pawtong doesn’t specify an expansion time in its specs, but I’d still give any compressed mattress at least 48 hours. Plan ahead — don’t unbox these the night before your baby comes home from the hospital.
Which mattress is easiest to clean after diaper leaks?
The DeerFable is the clear winner here because of its built-in waterproof inner lining with a 0.1mm ultra-thin membrane that stops leaks without feeling stiff. The foctance has a machine-washable cover, but doesn’t mention a waterproof layer underneath. The Pawtong is the weakest of the three for leaks since it has no waterproof protection at all — spills will soak into the foam.
Which mattress is lightest and easiest to lift for sheet changes?
The DeerFable is shockingly light at just 3.74 pounds, making it incredibly easy to lift one-handed while holding a baby. The foctance is more than double that weight at 9 pounds, and the Pawtong doesn’t list its weight but feels heavier than the DeerFable. If you’re changing sheets frequently, the DeerFable saves your back.
My Final Verdict
The DeerFable Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress is my clear overall winner. Its 8-layer construction, dual OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US certifications, and built-in waterproof membrane give you safety and durability that the 3-layer Pawtong and foctance simply can’t match. The Pawtong is a solid runner-up if you want a higher customer rating at 4.8 stars, and the foctance is your best bet if cooling is the only thing you care about.
If you’re still on the fence, think about this: the DeerFable is the only mattress here with a dedicated newborn firm side at 70D density and a toddler soft side at 40D, plus it weighs just 3.74 pounds for easy sheet changes. That combination of safety, versatility, and convenience makes it the smartest choice for most families.
Winner: DeerFable Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress
- [Dual Certifications & Premium Safety Materials] As a baby crib mattress, it...
- [Dual Firmness & Cool-Warm Fabric, One Mattress for 0-3 Years] Tailored to...
- [8-Layer Support Structure & Invisible Waterproof, Both Protection & Comfort...
Best for parents who want the safest, most versatile mattress from newborn through toddler years with 8 layers of protection, dual firmness, and a waterproof lining that actually works.
Runner-Up: Pawtong Crib Mattress
- Usable For Babies and Toddlers: Our crib mattress for babies and toddlers have...
- Soft Removable Cover: Our mattress cover fabric is ice silk on one side and all...
- Breathable and Comfortable Mattress: Our crib mattress is made of a three-layer...
Best for parents who prioritize customer reviews and want a pocketed coil mattress with gel memory foam for temperature control at a thinner 4.5-inch profile.
Best for Cooling: foctance Crib Mattress
- 【Double-sided Mattress Cover】The mattress cover is suitable for all...
- 【Triple Layer Foam】 This advanced triple-layer mattress integrates...
- 【Easy Removable & Clean】 Engineered with lock-stitch seams and a...
Best for parents with hot-sleeping babies who need maximum airflow from gel-infused and open-cell memory foam, plus a cooling fiber cover side for summer.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.