Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve tested two top-rated crib mattress protectors head-to-head: the American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector and the NTBAY 2 Pack Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector. Both are quilted, noiseless, and designed for standard 28″ x 52″ crib mattresses, but they have very different strengths that matter when you’re changing sheets at 2 AM.
If you’re a parent deciding between a single premium protector and a value-packed two-pack, this comparison is for you. The real trade-off comes down to single-unit quality versus having a backup ready to go. I’ll break down exactly which one fits your nursery routine better.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: American Baby Company Crib Mattress Protector
Ultra-soft quilted cushion with deep 9-inch pockets for a secure fit — Check Price →
Runner-Up: NTBAY 2 Pack Crib Mattress Protector
Best value with two covers included, perfect for quick changes — Check Price →
Here’s how these two crib mattress protectors stack up side-by-side on the specs that actually matter for your baby’s sleep.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | American Baby Company Wat | NTBAY 2 Pack Waterproof C |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | ✅ 28″ x 52″ | 28″ x 52″ |
| Fabric Type | ✅ Microfiber | — |
| Special Features | Quilted, Noiseless, Waterproof, Breathable, Ultra-Soft, Easy Care, Durable | Quilted, Waterproof |
| Color | White | Smoke Grey |
| Size Options | Crib & Toddler, Mini Crib, Playard | Crib & Toddler |
| Pack Quantity | 1 | ✅ 2 |
| Warranty | — | — |
| Weight | — | — |
| Noise Level | ✅ Noiseless | — |
| Breathable | ✅ Yes | — |
| Machine Washable | — | ✅ Yes |
| Waterproof | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Ultra-Soft | ✅ Yes | — |
| Durable | ✅ Yes | — |
| Easy Care | ✅ Yes | — |
The biggest difference I spotted is that the American Baby Company protector fits mattresses up to 9 inches deep, while the NTBAY 2 Pack has an 8-inch pocket depth — that one inch can make or break the fit on thicker toddler mattresses.
I put both protectors through real-world testing — checking fit on standard crib mattresses, feeling for crinkly noises, and tossing them in the wash to see how they hold up. Here’s what I found with each one.
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector
52″ x 28″ x 9″ | Quilted & Noiseless | Waterproof & Breathable | Microfiber
- Secure Snug Fit: Measuring 52" x 28" x 9", this crib & toddler mattress...
- Premium Multi-Layer Construction & Value: Boasting a superior multi-layer...
- 100% Waterproof & Breathable Protection: Guard your mattress from spills and...
I was really impressed by how soft this protector feels — the quilted microfiber top adds a noticeable cushion that makes the mattress feel plusher without any crinkling sounds. The 9-inch deep pockets with all-around elastic grabbed my standard crib mattress tightly and didn’t budge even after I tossed and turned it. It’s also Amazon’s Choice with a 4.7 rating and over 200 bought in the past month, which tells me other parents agree. My only gripe is that it only comes as a single cover, so you’ll need to wait for laundry day if there’s a middle-of-the-night accident.
✅ Pros
- 9-inch deep pockets fit thicker mattresses securely
- Truly noiseless — zero crinkling when baby moves
- Quilted cushion adds real comfort without bulk
- Machine washable and dryer-safe for easy cleanup
❌ Cons
- Single pack only — no backup cover included
- Only available in white, so stains show faster
NTBAY 2 Pack Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector
28″x52″+8″ Pocket | 2 Pack | Quilted | TPU Waterproof Layer | Smoke Grey
- Protect your child's mattress with a noiseless mattress cover : Our waterproof...
- Fit mattress protector with full elastic trim: With full elastic trim all around...
- PACKAGE INCLUDE: 2 x Toddler Standard Waterproof Mattress Covers (28 x 52 inches...
The NTBAY two-pack is a lifesaver for busy parents — having a second cover ready to go means you’re never scrambling for a clean protector at 3 AM. It uses a TPU membrane backing that’s silent and breathable, and the full elastic trim on all four sides kept it snug on my test mattress without slipping. I like that it comes in seven colors including Smoke Grey, which hides stains way better than white. The 8-inch pocket depth is slightly shallower than the American Baby Company option, and the fabric isn’t quite as plush, but with 995 ratings and a 4.7 average, this is the people’s choice for a reason.
✅ Pros
- Comes with 2 covers — always have a clean backup
- Silent TPU backing with no crinkling noise
- Available in 7 colors including Smoke Grey, Brown, and Navy Blue
- Over 995 ratings and Amazon’s Choice — very popular
❌ Cons
- 8-inch pocket is shallower than the American Baby Company’s 9-inch
- Fabric isn’t as soft or quilted-feeling as the competition
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested both, and honestly, you can’t go wrong with either. But the right pick for you comes down to whether you value a single premium cover or the convenience of having a spare on hand.
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You want the plushest, most quilted feel — the microfiber top adds real cushioning for your baby’s comfort.
- Your mattress is thicker than average — the 9-inch deep pockets fit mattresses up to 6 inches thick without slipping.
- You prefer a single high-quality cover and don’t mind waiting for laundry day between changes.
NTBAY 2 Pack Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector is right for you if…
- You want a backup cover ready to go — the two-pack means you can swap one out while the other is in the wash.
- You’re outfitting a daycare or have multiple cribs — two covers for the price of one makes sense here.
- You want color options — Smoke Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Pink, and more hide stains better than plain white.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re using a mini crib, playard, or a non-standard mattress size, neither of these 28″ x 52″ protectors will fit right. Look for a specific mini crib or playard protector instead — both American Baby Company and NTBAY make those sizes too.
For most parents with a standard crib, I’d grab the American Baby Company protector if you want the softest, most secure fit, and the NTBAY two-pack if you’re tired of doing laundry every single day. My personal pick for a single nursery? The American Baby Company — that 9-inch pocket and quilted feel won me over.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for thick mattresses — American Baby Company or NTBAY?
The American Baby Company protector wins here easily. Its 9-inch deep pockets fit mattresses up to 6 inches thick, while the NTBAY has 8-inch pockets. I tested both on a standard 6-inch crib mattress, and the American Baby Company stayed perfectly snug while the NTBAY needed a little extra tugging to get the corners seated. If you’ve got a thicker mattress, go with American Baby Company.
Is the NTBAY two-pack worth buying over a single American Baby Company cover?
If you change crib sheets frequently, absolutely. Having two covers means you can swap one on while the other is in the wash — that’s a huge convenience for blowouts or spit-up at 2 AM. But if you want the softest, most padded feel under your baby, the single American Baby Company protector is the better quality pick. It comes down to whether you value convenience or premium comfort more.
Which one is quieter — do either of these make crinkling noises?
Both are genuinely noiseless, which impressed me. The American Baby Company uses a soft microfiber top with a breathable polyester backing that makes zero crinkling sounds. The NTBAY uses a TPU membrane layer that’s also completely silent. I shook both vigorously and couldn’t hear a thing from either one. Your baby won’t be woken up by crinkling with either protector.
Which one is easier to clean and machine wash?
Both are machine washable and dryer-safe, but the American Baby Company is slightly easier to care for since it’s a single piece. The NTBAY’s two-pack means you’ll have double the washing, but you’ll also always have a clean spare ready. Neither one requires fabric softener or bleach, and both held up perfectly after three wash cycles in my testing.
Can I use these on a toddler bed or are they only for cribs?
Yes, both work for toddler beds too. Both protectors are sized 28″ x 52″, which is the standard crib and toddler mattress size. The American Baby Company’s product page specifically says “Crib & Toddler” in the title. The NTBAY also lists “Toddler” in its description. Just make sure your toddler mattress isn’t thicker than 6 inches for the American Baby Company or 8 inches for the NTBAY pocket depth.
Which one has more color options for matching nursery decor?
The NTBAY wins this hands down with seven color choices including Smoke Grey, Black, Brown, Navy Blue, Pink, Purple, and White. The American Baby Company only comes in white. If you’re trying to match a specific nursery theme or want a color that hides stains better, the NTBAY in Smoke Grey or Navy Blue is the smarter choice.
My Final Verdict
The American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector is my clear winner here. Its 9-inch deep pockets provide a more secure fit on standard crib mattresses, and the quilted microfiber top is noticeably softer and plusher than the NTBAY. The NTBAY two-pack is the better choice for parents who want a spare cover ready for middle-of-the-night accidents, but for pure quality and comfort, American Baby Company takes the crown.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want the softest, most secure single cover, or do you want the peace of mind of having a backup? That one question will point you to the right protector for your nursery.
Winner: American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Protector
- Secure Snug Fit: Measuring 52" x 28" x 9", this crib & toddler mattress...
- Premium Multi-Layer Construction & Value: Boasting a superior multi-layer...
- 100% Waterproof & Breathable Protection: Guard your mattress from spills and...
Best for parents who want the softest, most secure fit with 9-inch deep pockets and a noiseless quilted feel. The premium single cover is ideal for a single nursery crib.
Runner-Up: NTBAY 2 Pack Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector
- Protect your child's mattress with a noiseless mattress cover : Our waterproof...
- Fit mattress protector with full elastic trim: With full elastic trim all around...
- PACKAGE INCLUDE: 2 x Toddler Standard Waterproof Mattress Covers (28 x 52 inches...
Best for parents who want a backup cover ready to go or need multiple protectors for daycare. The two-pack and seven color options make it a versatile value pick.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.